Quote:
Originally Posted by DJ's left nut
We also know what we have in Caliendo. And it was shite.
Moreover, in 2 of the 3 games Thuney played at LT he wasn't any better than Humphries was today.
Given that we're probably going to play the Chargers in the Divisional, I think I'd go Thuney. We can play a pretty tight, mistake free offense and win that game. The only way we lose it is if we turn the ball over.
But at the same time, that will firmly close the door on Humphries and I think we just might need more than that in the AFCCG and SB.
It's just a much harder decision than some are making it, IMO. Thuney has definitely not been the rock wall some are suggesting at LT and Caliendo has looked real bad the last two weeks.
As a couch warrior I want to see Humphries. If I were in Andy's chair, I'm not sure I could talk myself into it.
|
The way I rationalize it is, would you be okay losing with Thuney or Humphries at LT?
Personally, if we lose with Thuney, I'll believe we lost with our best possible OL situation out there. I can live with that.
I absolutely cannot live with losing with Humphries when I can trust my own eyes and see the offense performing at it's highest level when Thuney was there at LT.
If there was more time to flesh out this idea with Humphries, I'd be on board. But we are sadly very much out of time.