[melbar]

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58

Convenient for me?

My list has been the same throughout. I don't agree with a lot of what the so-called experts say. I watch as many guys play as possible and then form my own opinions.

McFadden is a great example.

I think Mendenhall and even Felix Jones will have better pro careers than McFadden.

My list, in "tier" form, as you listed yours: (no particular order)

Tier A: C. Long, Dorsey, Ellis, Gholston, J. Long

Tier B: Ryan, Rivers, Mendenhall, Rodgers-Cromartie, C. Williams

Tier C: D. Harvey, Mike Jenkins, McKelvin, Otah, Stewart

No Clady at all?

I pretty much agree with your list except for Gholston and Clady to B and I'd switch Jenkins and McKelvin with Rogers-Cromartie. DRC didnt play in college to the level that his talent is. Sort of like Woolfork a couple of years ago.