Quote:
Originally Posted by Mecca
Well Ben Roethlisberger was an underclassman...
I can throw up alot of arguments about why it's felt to be important. Most guys who declared early were big stat, system guys who wanted to get paid..Akili Smith comes to mind a guy who failed as a baseball player then returned to college to play football had his 1 good season and bolted.
Most of the time people don't like to take underclassmen because they haven't been well coached and they are unrefined so they'll need more work. The fact is with a guy like Sanchez he's been well coached he isn't going to learn anything else in college...
There are a huge list of seniors that have failed aswell, hell when you get out of the 1st round you're talking about basically a 5% chance of finding a franchise QB yet people always seem to want to do that.
It's about finding a guy who has the natural physical talent, the makeup and intangibles to lead your team and your franchise a guy with the desire to live and breathe nothing but the game so much so watching film is something he wants and loves to do not something he considers work.
I think Sanchez has the makeup to be a successful QB and he has supreme physical talent, and he's been very well coached in a pro style offense he properly drops, takes snaps and sets up and throws properly.
He's had responsibility for plays at SC you don't see him looking to the sideline for audibles.
I think the experience thing would mean something if you could show me something he doesn't do well because he needs more experience but that isn't the case with this guy.
I'm going to borrow a post I saw on another forum because it sums up the underclassmen QB thing pretty well...
|
Quote:
|
Simple minded people don't understand rules like 'junior QB's never pan out' are nonsense. Just because junior QB's in the past have had a poor track record does not mean some cosmic force will prevent future one's from having good careers. A BS rule about junior QB's mean as much as the old rule "rookie QB's never play well".
|
Spot on, and I'm making some room in my sig for that quote as we speak.