[OnTheWarpath15]

Originally Posted by Just Passin' By

Genius.... I don't have anything to do with WPI. I've never even visited the place, although I've read some of the threads where you people have pounded that site.

Now, let's compare Anderson and Manning:

Anderson: 43 touchdowns, 35 interceptions, which is a 1.228/1 ratio
Manning: 98 touchdowns, 74 interceptions, which is a 1.324/1 ratio

Anderson's career passer rating is 75.1, Manning's is 76.1

Anderson's career average is 6.7 yards per attempt, Manning's is 6.4 ypa

Anderson's career TD% is 4.6, Manning's is 4.3
Anderson's career INT% is 3.8, Manning's is 3.2

Their stats are pretty comparable, and Anderson's done it on a far worse team.

No, their stats AREN'T comparable, because Manning has done that over FOUR seasons, and has won a CHAMPIONSHIP, while Anderson has done that over 1 season.

Here's Eli's stats:



Know what I see there?

Consistency, and a guy who's taken a beating. (And a Championship)

Here's Anderson's:



Know what I see there?

1 solid season, sandwiched between 2 garbage seasons.

Sorry, but you have to be missing some crucial part of the critical thinking process if you think Eli Manning has been a disappointment, and Derek Anderson has been a success.

And with that, I'm off to bed.