I missed this thread since I haven't been on here in awhile. Both players are awesome and I would love to have either roaming in our secondary, but if I had to choose I would have to take Eric Berry. While not as big and probably not as fast as Mays, he's the bigger playmaker between the two - think Ed Reed in the secondary. Dude looked dominant in today's UF - UT game.
Again, I am not going to argue vehemently in his favor over Mays because they are both studs, but in my eyes Berry is the better college player and will be the better pro player.
|