Quote:
Originally Posted by 'Hamas' Jenkins
Then perhaps you should ground your critiques in stats and evidence and not become so inured to the idea that Manning is better that you lose any pretense of objectivity.
You can't conduct an argument without resorting to pure propaganda, and that's why you always fail in convincing people. There's no acknowledgement of the merits of the other side whatsoever. It's Peyton Manning is the greatest and Tom Brady is the worst. It's Fox News levels of intelligence.
If you want people to believe that Manning is better than Brady, at least be intellectually honest enough to give Brady some credit, because whether or not you like it, he's a hall of fame quarterback.
|
I've always admitted he is a hall of fame QB...
and I've always stood by my reasoning why he is a hall of fame QB...
He's a talented guy...the Patriots made him a game manager in 2001...and he did an amazing job...he did exactly what the coaching staff asked him to do...the Patriots won a Super Bowl...he didn't **** up...they probably cheated (how else do they hold the Rams to 3 points through 3 quarters???)...but that's beside the point...the Patriots beat the Rams...Tom Brady was the QB...
Suddenly this young 6th round pick is a Super Bowl winner...he gains all sorts of confidence and swagger...they trade Bledsoe..he's the toast of town...can do no wrong...
Confident guy, lots of swagger...suddenly he becomes TOM BRADY...
Plain and simple...that's what a Super Bowl can do for a guy...
If Tom Brady was the Chiefs 6th round pick...what are the odds he's our starting QB in 2010? What are the odds that he's TOM BRADY...1st ballot hall of famer?
Exactly.
If we won the Peyton Manning lottery...
Would the Chiefs have set the record for most wins in a decade?
How about the Bengals? Browns?
Peyton Manning was destined for greatness no matter what...he's a once in a lifetime QB...best QB of all time...as perfect as we'll ever see...
Tom Brady...1st ballot hall of famer...tripped into the perfect situation...
you can try and deflect all you want but what's true is true