[TheGuardian]

Originally Posted by The Bad Guy

Pretty good job? Based on what grading scale?

Just because Vermeil sucked that doesn't give Herm a pass.

He had one draft that was very productive.

His 2006 draft was a pretty big pile of shit. There are just 3 picks from that draft still on the roster - Hali (good pick), Croyle (ehh), Page (good pick considering).
From the 2007 draft, we have TWO players still on the roster - Bowe (good pick), Kolby Smith (nothing great).

Think about that for one second. The 2006 and 2007 drafts gave us just 5 players with only 2 being starters. 2 ****ing players in drafts from 3-4 years ago. That's horrendus.

The 2008 draft was very good. Generally though, having 2 first round picks is a big advantage. Hitting on Flowers and Charles though is big time.

There is a massive myth on here that Herm was a really good drafter for this team.

Hali, Flowers, Carr, Page, Albert, Dorsey are all starters. Letting go of Pollard was also a big mistake. So WTF are you talking about?