Quote:
Originally Posted by 'Hamas' Jenkins
Who is worth more:
An outside linebacker in a 3-4 who can harass the QB
A 0 technique who can command consistent double teams
A potential franchise QB
A slot receiver with size and speed
A legit #2 receiver
or Dave Meggett
I think McCluster's absolute upside is Dave Meggett.
He'll be a good player, but he's not worth more than the above.
|
I disagree.
The Kindle and Cody both went to teams that are loaded defensively and are able to take chances (medical and physical/mental) on boom or bust players. The Chiefs cannot at this point in time.
If McCluster's upside is Meggett on the field, sign me up! He was instrumental in those Giants offenses in the 80's and key to their Super Bowl appearances.
I'll take productivity and playmaking over boom or bust guys any day of the week in 2010.