Found it, Guillen's run is unearned, but everyone after him is still earned. A very obscure scoring rule applies to this game. This is the only situation I know of where a batter-runner reaching on an error can later score an unearned run with 2 outs, but it has no impact on determining if other runs are unearned.
Quote:
|
A runner who reaches on catcher's interference and subsequently scores with two outs scores an unearned run, but baserunners who subsequently score after the runner who has reached on catcher's interference exclusively on clean plays score earned runs; the baserunner cannot be assumed to have been put out except for the error. (Rule 10.16(4)).
|
I guess that means if there was 1 out, everything would have been earned? Weird.