Quote:
Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58
So, you're saying the same thing everyone else said.
People bitched about the pick because he couldn't stay healthy in college, not because of a lack of talent.
But why let the facts get in the way?
|
This is true about some posters...others lambasted the kid over and over before and after the draft saying over and over "the guy is no better than the 17th ranked tight end in this class on ANY draft site"
Well before the draft I had multiple arguments with many posters here about his ability to be a total player. I compare(d) him to Visante Shiancoe as a receiver (and got laughed at for my efforts, just wait till Cassel develops, or we get a real quarterback in here he will be a deadly weapon in the passing game) and he is one of the best tight ends in the NFL as a blocker. I pointed out over and over how well he helped shut down Derrick Morgan in their bowl game while having a damn good receiving game and helping for us seal the edge on running plays all in the same bowl game.
Quote:
Originally Posted by okiedokieokoye
We moved up 9 spots to get Tony. We lost our 4th round pick to do this. That's not a huge sacrifice by any means.
|
We lost our fourth rounder and a late fifth rounder in the trade for a player that could very well be a perennial probowl player if he is able to avoid the fluke injuries he suffered in college.
Quote:
Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58
You're absolutely correct.
I don't recall anyone disputing his talent.
I do, however, recall people not being thrilled that we traded up, when we could have had him, or someone as talented with our original pick. And people were concerned that he missed something like 26 of Iowa's 52 games while he was there.
And there were people that weren't thrilled with the fact that the regime had traded up to take a TE two years running.
|
haha
if you still think that there were multiple other "just as talented" players available there, you don't watch blocking very much and just care about the receptions a tight end gets.
Put Moeaki on the Patriots and he would look like a much better player overall than Hernandez, which is a receiving tight end, not a complete player.
...
Also, I cant believe you guys still bitch about Pioli trading a future seventh round pick to get back into the 7th round of last years draft to take a player with a good size/speed ratio for a position of need. You cant win em all (or in the case of the 2009 draft, you cant win at all)
...
So far, Tony Moeaki has been our best draft pick!