Quote:
Originally Posted by Omega
 @ you guys who think you are smarter than Football Outsiders and PFF.
****ing idiots. Accept the truth. We could cut McCluster, replace him with a late draft pick, and probably notice 0 difference other than dreadlock swing. |
I obviously am smarter than PFF since at least I know enough to know what the word ELUSIVE means. Football Outsiders is more reasonable but do you HONESTLY feel that Ben Tate is better than AP?
These type of ranking systems leave far far far too much to be desired.
As for McCluster, I don't think he is anything super-special, but he certainly isn't the scrub you seem to think he is.
Let's look at the two lists you used...
According to FO .. he is better than Felix Jones, Marion Barber and Frank Gore...
According to PFF he is better than Mark Ingram, Ryan Grant and Ricky Williams...
Are these really the sources you want to use to back up your argument?