Quote:
Originally Posted by Peyton's Princess
  
so he was 18th when he played 8 games on a site that accumulates rankings as you play...meaning he projected to be right where Matt Schaub was (or 12th) had he played all 16 games.
and earlier you said 2011 was a better indicator of the kind of player Sean Smith is (I'm not sure why)...but now 2012 is the year to judge Alex Smith (even though he projected to be about the same as 2011)...
you're awesome
|
We're talking about two different players, and I didn't say 2012 was the year to judge Alex Smith. Nowhere did I say that.
Alex Smith isn't going to win 13 games IN KANSAS CITY doing what he did in San Francisco. Period.