Quote:
Originally Posted by cdcox
Okay, I see that he was Hottieing.
The question then becomes, why doesn't our QB have a Joe Montana ceiling? Geno certainly does (remember Joe was a 3rd round draft pick).
|
I'm just tired of Clay parading around every thread with his PFF rankings...but when they don't fit his argument he conveniently ignores them or in Alex Smith's case...dismisses them.
and then he says something ridiculous like the following:
Matt Cassel = Alex Smith because in 2010 his best game was equivalent to Alex Smith's best game.
In which case, I countered that OUTRAGEOUS argument by saying Alex Smith's 2012 game against the Arizona Cardinals @ Arizona against a great pass defense was Joe Montana-esque because he was:
18 for 19 and had 4 TD's and played a perfect game.
Which means Alex Smith = Joe Montana because he did it one time. (Actually twice he graded out perfectly in QBR against Buffalo in 2012 too)