Quote:
Originally Posted by cdcox
When everything goes well you get 2010 Matt Cassel. To me that is Matt Cassel's ceiling. That's what I thought his ceiling was when we acquired him. Alex Smith's 2011 isn't that different from Matt Cassel's 2010. Smith might be a little more consistent, might have a little higher ceiling. But if you push him like Reid's offense will, I think he could crack. I don't think he will blossom in to a top 8 QB.
|
ok fine whatever
but Clay parades around like PFF is THE BE ALL END ALL way to evaluate NFL players...
Matt Cassel had a NEGATIVE RATING in 2010 despite throwing 27 TD's and 7 INT's
Alex Smith was the 8th best rated QB by PFF in 2011.
So something isn't adding up.
Either Alex Smith = Matt Cassel and PFF is the biggest fraudulent site in the history of statistics (which could be)
or Clay is a cherry picking troll (which is probably true)