Quote:
Originally Posted by jd1020
What exactly are their past bodies of work?
Reid hasn't done anything since McNabb.
And what exactly did Dorsey do in GB? He was a scout and then became an assistant. There's nothing to suggest he was calling any shots. All we have to go by is what he's done in KC and the first thing he did was spend the #34 pick and a 2014 3rd/2nd on Alex Smith.
|
Andy Reid is a terrific offensive coach and his offense has consistently been very good. He hasn't been a consistent winner since struggling to find a defensive identity. But that's not what we're arguing about here. We're arguing primarily about his knowledge of offense and offensive players.
Dorsey looks raw from the GM side, but you're questioning his ability to scout players and not giving him credit for his contribution to Green Bay success. That's wrong. We will see how good Dorsey really is based on how some of our late picks do.
I agree that both have had a so-so track record of finding QBs. But Dorsey never really had to, and Reid has proven he can get the most out of QBs (even the bad ones).