Quote:
Originally Posted by Maverick91579
So what if the Chiefs make the playoffs, and win a playoff game?
|
It would be cool to win a playoff game for the first time since 1993. I won't deny that. Whether I change my tune on Alex Smith depends on how they win the playoff game.
A playoff win like the one against the Saints, followed by a loss in the next round where Alex Smith can't make consistent plays against a good D and can't keep his offense on the field? Doesn't do much for me other than break the embarrassing streak of complete postseason failure.
It's not Alex Smith's general competence I question. He's an OK NFL starter, and as long as Andy Reid and co. treat him like that and nothing more, there's no long term damage. What I question is Smith's ability to be the QB who makes plays against elite teams and good defenses in elimination settings.
Making the playoffs and winning a game with Alex Smith is not necessarily a good thing, either. I imagine they'd extend him regardless, if they win a playoff game. Even if he is merely a bystander to winning the game rather than the lynchpin, and probably even if he shits the bed in the next round again.