Quote:
Originally Posted by Maverick91579
Still incorrect. I said, Alex Smith is better in the San Francisco offense, than Matt Stafford would be, and I agreed with you, that in the Detroit offense, even with Calvin Johnson, that Alex Smith would suck.
You really need to understand what I am trying to say.......
No. I do not think Alex Smith is a very good NFL qb. I think he is an average NFL qb, whose best trait is that he doesn't turn the ball over. He is accurate on short passes. he has no problems checking into a run. he has shown to be clutch at times, but cant carry your team.
Pre snap, he is one of the best, he can pick up a system and has zero ego.
That is all I have ever said about Alex Smith. I think some day he can be a hell of a coach. But a damn good nfl qb? Pffff. no, never.
I have also said multiple times that if Andy Reid decides that Alex Smith can do what he asked Donovan McNabb, and Michael Vick to do, hes crazy, and the Chiefs will win 5 games max. That is all I have ever said......
|
I like you as a poster, you seem fairly knowledgeable.
But what you need to realize is that this was exactly what was said here 4 years ago when Cassel was brought in. Almost to a T.
That said, I think Smith is better than Cassel, but up to this point, yes, their numbers aren't much different.