Quote:
Originally Posted by RippedmyFlesh
Then you will be pleased. You can hate all you want but Smith has significantly more talent than castle. You set the bar at castle's best I think it should be higher because he has more talent. Remains to be seen if we get that production but the talent is there to expect more without being delusional.
|
smith has significantly more natural skill than cassel but he hasn't been a significantly better player.
Imo Cassel and Smith are in the same classification of QB.
A - franchise QB that makes players around him better
B - Winning elite QB
C - competent QB that can play on a winning team
D - backup that you don't want playing for any extended length of time
F - Not NFL level
A - Brady,Manning
B - Flacco,Roethlisberger
C - Alex Smith(C+)Matt Cassel(C-)