[the Talking Can]

Originally Posted by Marcellus

In fairness you have to believe 10 games into last season he was taking them to the playoffs, that was a lock.

And really who knows what happens if he is the QB the whole season into the playoffs? (minus the 1 game due to injury) He took that same team to the brink of a SB so he could have done it again or made it to the SB.

Anyone who says they KNOW he couldn't have is being disingenuous.

actually, he was benched and traded

it's funny how we can't talk about it...he's this amazing, clutch, non-injury prone QB who...for no reason anyone could guess, was targeted to be replaced by his new coach

Harbaugh took one look at Smith and knew he had to draft his own QB, and he did, then he slapped a leash on Smith, then benched him, and then traded him...oh yeah, and then went to the Superbowl

repeat: Alex Smith, not good enough for the best young coach in the league

prior to Harbaugh slapping a leash on him, he had 5 years of proving nothing...in the last 5 years he has played more than 11 games exactly ONCE

but listening to you guys, damn, he's this swashbuckling, strong armed, injury free god who carried the 49ers to the Super...err, to the bench

and according to our resident Smith stalker, he has a golden rod and children with large vulvas and shining morals...not that he cares or anything (to the tune of 100 posts per day about alex smith)

so, carry on with the Chiefs Tiger Beat Coverage of our dreamy new stud fresh off a California bench