Quote:
Originally Posted by SanDiego49er
Come on "Kaepernick." Eli is not elite. LOL. He's clutch as hell, aggressive, accurate, better when you need him, won 2 Super Bowls. And his arm is stronger than given credit for. He's super elite.
|
Eli Manning is not an elite QB.
Elite QBs like Brady and Rodgers are consistent. Eli is "feast or famine". His upside is that he has enormous smarts and courage, so he will attack at the pivotal moment, and when it works he gets a SB ring. That is a wonderful trait.
At other times he is foolhardy and makes boneheaded mistakes and kills his team.
Elite QBs are not inconsistent QBs. Eli is inconsistent.
I'm not knocking the guy. He is nearly elite. He is an easy top 8 QB.