Ditto. You probably can't replace Manning completely (certainly not with Vick), but you can get someone who isn't as much of a step down from him as your current RBs are from LaDainian Tomlinson. Make the trade and see what QBs are available in your free agent pool. Even if you have to go with Vick, you're better off making the trade.

The verdict is in. Thanks to all.

in my league Vick is a solid fantasy QB because you get 1 point per 10 yards rushing, but I would probably do it...because LT's stock is probably low right now and Peyton isn't putting up the big passing numbers and he wouldn't have as many fantasy points already if he hadn't ran for a couple of TDs this year (which I doubt will happen again)...that's just me though

What was the verdict? Can't be bad to have either Peyton or LdT, so either way, good luck to ya.

I made a counter offer. Manning and D. Foster for Tomlinson and Muhammad. I need a solid #3 reciever and Muhammad is extremely better than previous #3 reciever. No he is not Berrian, but still. IF the trade goes through here is my team...
QB- Vick
RB- Tomlinson
RB- T. Jones
WR - M. Harrison
WR - P. Burress
WR - Muhammad
TE - Crumpler
D - Broncos
K - Tynes

No doubt...I have a shot with this squad..sitting in third now...