Originally Posted by Amnorix
Ignoring the obvious choices:
I took Bradshaw over Green. I think Bradshaw is overrated, but Trent Green? C'mon...
Favre over Tarkenton, though in many ways they're the same guy, at least Favre won it all, etc.
I took Otto Graham over Elway. This is a tough match. Graham is an all-time great. He was All-Pro NINE times. Hell, his CAREER Passer Rating is 86.6, which is higher than Elway's.
MUCH higher than Elway's.
And of course I'm completely neutral on this.