Does a WR catch a touchdown?

[DJJasonp]

Originally Posted by WhiteWhale

I don't agree.

I think Alex is a very middling QB. He strong points are boring, and he's weak at everything that makes a QB exciting. He's certainly too expensive for the return. He's a frustrating QB to watch, but he's not Matt Cassel. Alex Smith won't win games for you, but Matt Cassel LOST GAMES because he was goddamn awful. I mean the hat gif is popular, but did people forget the game losing play he had right before that pathetic hat incompletion? He threw an INT on a screen pass that lost the game.

Alex is a helluva long way from my ideal QB, but he's much better than a turnover machine like Matt Cassel.

I respect your opinion - and of course there will be differences. And with a gun to my head, I would choose Alex over Cassel.

But at the end of the day, those two QBs are on the same tier of QBs to me.

Low-end QB1 to high-end QB2.