538 Calls Tom Brady the 43rd Clutchest Postseason QB

[Just Passin' By]

Originally Posted by Hootie 2.0

You've brought brilliant analysis to this thread.

So, the advanced statistics say a replacement level QB would've gone 13-13 in Brady started (and finished) playoff games and the same replacement level QB would've gone 8-16 in Manning started (and finished) playoff games.

And you're rebuttal is ...

"Uh Nate Silver is dumb. Hootie gotta Hootie."

Brilliant.

Tom Brady has had better postseason teams than Peyton Manning. That is the premise of the argument. Tell me why this isn't true?

You brought up a site with one lousy formula to defend another site with a lousy formula. When I pointed out the stupidity of that maneuver, your response was to bring up a third site that I hadn't mentioned in the thread.

You're an idiot.