Should the Chiefs have drafted Aaron Rodgers over Derrick Johnson?

[milkman]

Originally Posted by DaWolf

You don't have to do it. The Texans certainly didn't have to draft David Carr, and the Niners certainly didn't have to draft Alex Smith, and they'd have probably been better for it. It's not always a slam dunk...

I think both Carr and Smith were reaches, and certainly not in the same class as a gut like Matt Stafford.

Does that mean that Stafford will pan out?

No.

But I don't believe you should reach for a QB that high simply because he's the best in an otherwise bad class.

Though I thought that Rogers was the best in that badd class that Smith came out in.