Athlon Sports QB Power Rankings

[Gadzooks]

Originally Posted by Chiefs Pantalones

Eli and Dilfer aren't even in the same zipcode when discussing QBs. Eli is a franchise QB, Dilfer was not. Dilfer and Johnson were the last game managers to win a Super Bowl and the way the game is played now they were probably the last EVER.

But to put him at 4 is too high. Rivers is an example of QB who has better stats than Eli over the past 6 years. Roethlisbeger has the same amount of rings but they weren't as recent, so he's below Eli.
I'll put him in the lower half of the top ten but 4 is too high in my books.

[Chiefs Pantalones]

Originally Posted by Gadzooks

But to put him at 4 is too high. Rivers is an example of QB who has better stats than Eli over the past 6 years. Roethlisbeger has the same amount of rings but they weren't as recent, so he's below Eli.
I'll put him in the lower half of the top ten but 4 is too high in my books.

They are all the same to me man. Rivers, Brees, Eli, Brady, etc. They are all great QBs. I'm not picky. I'd take any in a heartbeat.

[Gadzooks]

Originally Posted by Chiefs Pantalones

They are all the same to me man. Rivers, Brees, Eli, Brady, etc. They are all great QBs. I'm not picky. I'd take any in a heartbeat.

Over Cassel? Really?

[Chiefs Pantalones]

Originally Posted by Gadzooks

Over Cassel? Really?

Wanna trade Rivers for Cassel? Please? Pretty please?