Who would you rather have drafting for the Chiefs?

[jAZ]

Dorsey, Reid and Co., or... The collective wisdom of ChiefsPlanet

[HolyHat]

I don't think it would be hard to beat this...and this is only round 1

Spoiler!

Year Pick Player Name Position College
2012 11 11 Dontari Poe DT Memphis
2011 26 26 Jonathan Baldwin WR Pittsburgh
2010 5 5 Eric Berry DB Tennessee
2009 3 3 Tyson Jackson DE Louisiana State
2008 5 5 Glenn Dorsey DT Louisiana State
2008 15 15 Branden Albert G Virginia
2007 23 23 Dwayne Bowe WR Louisiana State
2006 20 20 Tamba Hali DE Penn State
2005 15 15 Derrick O. Johnson LB Texas
2003 27 27 Larry Johnson RB Penn State
2002 6 6 Ryan Sims DT North Carolina
2000 21 21 Sylvester Morris WR Jackson State
1999 14 14 John Tait T Brigham Young
1998 27 27 Victor Riley T Auburn
1997 13 13 Tony Gonzalez TE California
1996 28 28 Jerome Woods DB Memphis
1995 31 31 Trezelle Jenkins T Michigan
1994 25 25 Greg Hill RB Texas A&M
1992 20 20 Dale Carter DB Tennessee
1991 21 21 Harvey Williams RB Louisiana State
1990 13 13 Percy Snow LB Michigan State
1989 4 4 Derrick Thomas LB Alabama
1988 2 2 Neil Smith DE Nebraska
1987 19 19 Paul Palmer RB Temple
1986 7 7 Brian Jozwiak T West Virginia
1985 15 15 Ethan Horton RB North Carolina
1984u 5 5 Mark Adickes T Baylor
1984 5 5 Bill Maas DT Pittsburgh
1984 21 21 John Alt T Iowa
1983 7 7 Todd Blackledge QB Penn State
1982 11 11 Anthony Hancock WR Tennessee
1981 14 14 Willie Scott TE South Carolina
1980 11 11 Brad Budde G USC
1979 2 2 Mike Bell DE Colorado State
1979 23 23 Steve Fuller QB Clemson
1978 2 2 Art Still DE Kentucky
1977 10 10 Gary Green DB Baylor
1976 14 14 Rod Walters G Iowa
1974 16 16 Woody Green RB Arizona State
1972 23 23 Jeff Kinney RB Nebraska
1971 16 16 Elmo Wright WR Houston
1970 26 26 Sid Smith T USC
1969 23 23 James Marsalis DB Tennessee State
1968 19 19 Mo Moorman G Texas A&M
1968 22 22 George Daney G Texas-El Paso
1967 24 24 Eugene Trosch DT Miami (FL)
1963 1 1 Buck Buchanan DT Grambling State

[HotCarl]

We'd probably end up with a few decent players, but we'd severely overpay for every one of them.

[Messier]

Soren Petro talks about the draft and fans saying I'd be better than these guys, and after a player taken later, fans come out and say, I liked him, that was my guy, like Russell Wilson.

So he says, every year the day of the draft write down who you would take right before the Chiefs draft, for every pick, and keep a log of your actual picks, you'll be surprised that you won't just have great draft after great draft. Sometimes the Chiefs will do better than you, sometimes you might draft better, but it won't be as often as you'd think.

[oldandslow]

Yeah, we would be dealing with Mark Sanchez and Vernon Ghoulston instead of Tyson Jackson and Glenn Dorsey...

kinda fail all the way around imo....lol

[wazu]

In the "Alternate Reality" Chiefs game that Rainman set up four years ago, every planeteer that participated has so far done better than the real Chiefs. I expect that will continue.

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

damn straight.
Posted via Mobile Device

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

Originally Posted by HotCarl

We'd probably end up with a few decent players, but we'd severely overpay for every one of them.

does it hurt your brain when you read curious george to start your day?
Posted via Mobile Device

[Rausch]

Originally Posted by oldandslow

Yeah, we would be dealing with Mark Sanchez and Vernon Ghoulston instead of Tyson Jackson and Glenn Dorsey...

kinda fail all the way around imo....lol

My record is only about 50/50 but that's much better than KC has done since 2001...

[jAZ]

For those who voted to trust "The collective wisdom of ChiefsPlanet", the results of this poll suggest you too should rather have "Dorsey, Reid and Co." running the draft. So there's that.

[COchief]

Hhmmmmmm... two guys who get paid around 5 mil a piece per year and were each selected for only 32 available positions in the world vs guys who spend half their time watching youtube highlights and the other half in poop threads.

Very tough call, although there is the "Fat Scott" factor which does pose a serious challenge on how dumb an NFL big shot can be...but since we have two with equal power (basically, don't care what they told the media) I am definitely going with Andy Dorsey's opinion.

[TEX]

Originally Posted by Rausch

My record is only about 50/50 but that's much better than KC has done since 2001...

Yep.

[htismaqe]

Originally Posted by jAZ

For those who voted to trust "The collective wisdom of ChiefsPlanet", the results of this poll suggest you too should rather have "Dorsey, Reid and Co." running the draft. So there's that.

You're so much smarter than everybody else.

[Red Beans]

Collective wisdom eh?

[RealSNR]

If Dorsey/Reid go QB at 1, I don't give a **** who they select with rounds 2-7, but I'll trust them on it.

If they don't go QB at 1, then I want a do-over, this time with Chiefs Planet making that pick. And then Dorsey/Reid can have the rest of the draft because again, I don't give a flying **** about 2-7

[tooge]

Originally Posted by wazu

In the "Alternate Reality" Chiefs game that Rainman set up four years ago, every planeteer that participated has so far done better than the real Chiefs. I expect that will continue.

wht thread is that? I'l love to see it