Just how valuable is a QB?

[Nightfyre]

Originally Posted by DTLB58

I'm not against drafting a QBOTF, But we have learned these guys are a 50/50 bet. After the comments from the "experts" pre-draft about JaMarcus Russell and then what The majority of CP wanted in 2010.... Jimmy Clausen. Seriously, if there are folks here now that weren't then, the love was just as great and look how that turned out.

So, giving any comparisons, ceilings or not to a rookie from a SB MVP like Rodgers is just silly.

Geno Smith has the arm strength, mobility, and accuracy which compare to Aaron Rodgers. He also happens to throw really well on the run and from multiple arm angles like Rodgers. To say that his ceiling is Rodgers is not a stretch. It is certainly possible that he will never reach it. On the other hand, he has a chance to.

[Valiant]

Originally Posted by Nightfyre

Geno Smith has the arm strength, mobility, and accuracy which compare to Aaron Rodgers. He also happens to throw really well on the run and from multiple arm angles like Rodgers. To say that his ceiling is Rodgers is not a stretch. It is certainly possible that he will never reach it. On the other hand, he has a chance to.

This.

I would rather chance that then a lt or dt.