Hypothetical established players for #1 pick

[Hootie]

Originally Posted by jd1020

Tony Romo and Kaepernick? WTF?

Romo was fringe...but he has all of the tools a QB needs. Great release, plus arm, good pocket awareness, good mobility...I think the dysfunctional Cowboys franchise holds him back, but he is starting to come off as quite the choker even to an apologist like me.

Kaepernick no doubt.

[In58men]

Originally Posted by Capt Tasty Cheeks

Romo was fringe...but he has all of the tools a QB needs. Great release, plus arm, good pocket awareness, good mobility...I think the dysfunctional Cowboys franchise holds him back, but he is starting to come off as quite the choker even to an apologist like me.

Kaepernick no doubt.

Die slowly

[jd1020]

Originally Posted by Capt Tasty Cheeks

Romo was fringe...but he has all of the tools a QB needs. Great release, plus arm, good pocket awareness, good mobility...I think the dysfunctional Cowboys franchise holds him back, but he is starting to come off as quite the choker even to an apologist like me.

Kaepernick no doubt.

Romo is Brett Favre but he's missing the Favre.

I'd give a 4th round pick for him to be backup to Geno Smith.

[crazycoffey]

Originally Posted by Capt Tasty Cheeks

Romo was fringe...but he has all of the tools a QB needs. Great release, plus arm, good pocket awareness, good mobility...I think the dysfunctional Cowboys franchise holds him back, but he is starting to come off as quite the choker even to an apologist like me.

Kaepernick no doubt.

Romo is cassel with a slightly better arm. Slightly.... Romo has over kicked his coverage on the cowboys like he did with simpson

[milkman]

Originally Posted by Capt Tasty Cheeks

QB's:

Tom Brady
Peyton Manning
Eli Manning
Aaron Rodgers
Drew Brees
Russel Wilson
RGIII
Andrew Luck
Cam Newton
Tony Romo
Matt Ryan
Colin Kaepernick

Those are all of the QB's I'd trade the #1 this year for...I was 50/50 on Tony Romo but if Geno develops to be as good as Romo I'd totally be happy.

I think Tony Romo is under rated by a lot of people, but I would not trade the #1 for him.

I also would not trade the #1 for Cam Newton, in spite of the fact that he might be the most physically gifted of any of those QBs, because I seriously question the mental aspect of his talent.

Outside of QB, I would not trade the #1 overal for any other position.

Great players at any other position are just cogs, outstanding cogs to be sure, but just cogs, nonetheless.

If you don't have a QB, you are wasting your time.

[O.city]

Originally Posted by milkman

I think Tony Romo is under rated by a lot of people, but I would not trade the #1 for him.

I also would not trade the #1 for Cam Newton, in spite of the fact that he might be the most physically gifted of any of those QBs, because I seriously question the mental aspect of his talent.

Outside of QB, I would not trade the #1 overal for any other position.

Great players at any other position are just cogs, outstanding cogs to be sure, but just cogs, nonetheless.

If you don't have a QB, you are wasting your time.

I'd love to see, if they fire Rivera next year, Shannahan JR go run his system in Carolina with Cam.


I think he'd be a monster in that.

[Buckweath]

Originally Posted by milkman

I think Tony Romo is under rated by a lot of people, but I would not trade the #1 for him.

I also would not trade the #1 for Cam Newton, in spite of the fact that he might be the most physically gifted of any of those QBs, because I seriously question the mental aspect of his talent.

Outside of QB, I would not trade the #1 overal for any other position.

Great players at any other position are just cogs, outstanding cogs to be sure, but just cogs, nonetheless.

If you don't have a QB, you are wasting your time.

Best post in this thread.

You're very unlikely to ever win a SB if you don't have let's say a top 8 QB.

It's all about getting that elite QB IMO.

So I'd trade the pick only for Brady, Rodgers, Brees, Luck, Griffin, Roethlisberger ...

[ThaVirus]

Originally Posted by Capt Tasty Cheeks

I'd take 3 years of Peyton Manning for the #1 pick and the rest of our draft.

So would I.

[Mother****erJones]

Originally Posted by Capt Tasty Cheeks

QB's:

Tom Brady
Peyton Manning
Eli Manning
Aaron Rodgers
Drew Brees
Russel Wilson
RGIII
Andrew Luck
Cam Newton
Tony Romo
Matt Ryan
Colin Kaepernick

Those are all of the QB's I'd trade the #1 this year for...I was 50/50 on Tony Romo but if Geno develops to be as good as Romo I'd totally be happy.

Um as long as he doesnt fold in the big games like Romo does

[Hootie]

I think people are pretty unrealistic when it comes to this #1 pick.

Andrew Luck only?

really? really?

I listed 11 QB's and if Geno turns out to be as good as any one of them I'll be more than happy.

I'd happily trade the #1 for Colin Kaepernick.

[O.city]

Stay safe poverty ghost.


And no, I wouldn't give up the first pick for RGIII.

[Hoover]

I want a young QB so we can enjoy a decade of domination.

You can keep Manning and Brady. I could be convinced to take Rogers, but this is his 8th year in the league.

[Hootie]

basically, I just wanted to see what the expectations were:

so far I predicted as much...

we expect to get an Andrew Luck and some people went as far as to say they wouldn't trade it for anyone, not even Aaron Rodgers

which is ridiculous

[Rasputin]

Originally Posted by Capt Tasty Cheeks

basically, I just wanted to see what the expectations were:

so far I predicted as much...

we expect to get an Andrew Luck and some people went as far as to say they wouldn't trade it for anyone, not even Aaron Rodgers

which is ridiculous

First I don't have expectations that Geno Smith is going be an Andrew Luck. Aaron Rodgers would be ok for a few years maybe we get lucky & maybe not win a Super Bowl? There is no NO guarantee in this league for any QB to win a Super Bowl that we go after. What I want is to get our own QB from the draft that we can build a team around that has potential to be great. Geno Smith "could" be that guy. Maybe not but I sure the **** want to find out. I am sick and tired of retread QBs. I didn't want Joe ****ing Montana when we got him. I want our own QB to build a championship team around that could be great for a decade to come.

We can win with Geno Smith I have no doubt about it. We are too stupid of a franchise to find out.

[Bewbies]

For me the player would have to be young. For the #1 pick I want someone with 10 years of elite left in them.