Whos the better RB: Marshawn Lynch or Jamaal Charles?

[Anyong Bluth]

Not sure if this is really a debate. It's JC hands down. Lynch was criticized a lot before getting out of Buffalo.

[Deberg_1990]

Originally Posted by Anyong Bluth

. Lynch was criticized a lot before getting out of Buffalo.

watching him run the past few years its hard to believe Buffalo didnt want him anymore. WTF??

[Anyong Bluth]

Originally Posted by Deberg_1990

watching him run the past few years its hard to believe Buffalo didnt want him anymore. WTF??

He's didn't produce or was streaky at best- not all the blame should be placed on him for that of course.

[mcaj22]

Charles is way better but Lynch has been hilarious at media day this week

[Big Poppa Payne]

JC and it's not even close.

I don't even think Lynch is a top 5 back.

[mcaj22]

Originally Posted by npayne1978

JC and it's not even close.

I don't even think Lynch is a top 5 back.

I'd be curious if you can name four others (Currently)

Charles, McCoy, Peterson and then it gets very hairy if you're gonna throw out someone like Matt Forte that's not even realistic.

[Big Poppa Payne]

Originally Posted by mcaj22

I'd be curious if you can name for others (Currently)

Let me see.. off the top of my head I would say..

1) JC
2) AP
3) LeSean McCoy
4) Frank Gore
5) Matt Forte
6) Eddie Lacy
7) Marshawn Lynch

[OldSchool]

Originally Posted by npayne1978

Let me see.. off the top of my head I would say..

1) JC
2) AP
3) LeSean McCoy
4) Frank Gore
5) Matt Forte
6) Eddie Lacy
7) Marshawn Lynch

Uhhh . . . lol. Gore should not be there at this point in his career, neither should Lacy.

1. AP
2. Lesean McCoy
3. JC
4. Lynch
5. Forte
6. Morris
7. Murray
8. Gore
9. Lacy
10. Take your pick.

[Big Poppa Payne]

Originally Posted by OldSchool

Uhhh . . . lol. Gore should not be there at this point in his career, neither should Lacy.

1. AP
2. Lesean McCoy
3. JC
4. Lynch
5. Forte
6. Morris
7. Murray
8. Gore
9. Lacy
10. Take your pick.

I stopped reading when I saw McCoy ahead of JC.

[jspchief]

Originally Posted by mcaj22

I'd be curious if you can name four others (Currently)

Charles, McCoy, Peterson and then it gets very hairy if you're gonna throw out someone like Matt Forte that's not even realistic.

Why is Matt Forte not realistic?

[mcaj22]

Originally Posted by jspchief

Why is Matt Forte not realistic?

because I knew the only RB that could rival Lynch for top 5 spot would be Forte, since the first three are locked in. Then he went a threw out Frank Gore and the Eddie Laceys of the world and that's where you are just pulling legs for the sake of trying to win an argument.

I'd take Lynch over Matt Forte any day. There's an argument to be made there. But you can't say you'd take Lynch over AP, McCoy or Charles. So, yea, Marshawn Lynch is a top 5 NFL RB Currently.

[ThaVirus]

Originally Posted by npayne1978

I stopped reading when I saw McCoy ahead of JC.

Originally Posted by Urc Burry

Why? He did probably have the better season. Like I said I have them at 1a and 1b. I haven't seen anyone make the cuts he has since Barry

Originally Posted by npayne1978

He's a great back man don't get me wrong. Maybe I'm just biased towards JC.

LeSean McCoy has the illest juke moves in the league, but he's juke or bust. He runs with no power and goes down at the first sign of contact. That's why I think Jamaal is better.

[The Franchise]

Originally Posted by mcaj22

because I knew the only RB that could rival Lynch for top 5 spot would be Forte, since the first three are locked in. Then he went a threw out Frank Gore and the Eddie Laceys of the world and that's where you are just pulling legs for the sake of trying to win an argument.

I'd take Lynch over Matt Forte any day. There's an argument to be made there. But you can't say you'd take Lynch over AP, McCoy or Charles. So, yea, Marshawn Lynch is a top 5 NFL RB Currently.

Forte over Lynch.....every day of the week.

[TLO]

JC and it isn't close.

[Brock]

5.6 vs 4.2 hmm