Pre-Combine QB Poll V1.0

[Exoter175]

Originally Posted by I_AM_Chief

Barkley in the 2nd round if he was still there. Worst class ever though, watching Teddy Bridgewater right now makes me cry he isn't eligible. We are screwed with this scrub class of QB's.

I wouldn't call them scrubs. There is a ton of talent there, just not nearly the separation of talent we've seen the last 2 years.

[patteeu]

Why not include all the QBs likely to be in the draft? Or at least an "other" option?

[Exoter175]

Originally Posted by patteeu

Why not include all the QBs likely to be in the draft? Or at least an "other" option?

Because the Chiefs won't be picking anyone outside of these 5.

[patteeu]

Originally Posted by Exoter175

Because the Chiefs won't be picking anyone outside of these 5.

While that's probably true, the poll question was asking for our choice not our prediction.

Here's what your poll would have looked like the year future superstar Tom Brady was drafted:

0 Chad Pennington
0 Giovanni Carmazzi
0 Chris Redman
0 Tee Martin
0 Marc Bulger

Poll fail AFAIC.

[Sorter]

Originally Posted by patteeu

Why not include all the QBs likely to be in the draft? Or at least an "other" option?

Nassib, Wilson, and Barkley are all guys that IMO can be effective QBs as rookies.

Glennon needs a much better situation based on personnel/scheme to succeed IMO.

Bray needs to sit as well.

[Exoter175]

Originally Posted by Sorter

Nassib, Wilson, and Barkley are all guys that IMO can be effective QBs as rookies.

Glennon needs a much better situation based on personnel/scheme to succeed IMO.

Bray needs to sit as well.

Do you think Nassib will be taken ahead of Glennon and/or Bray?

[Sorter]

Originally Posted by Exoter175

Do you think Nassib will be taken ahead of Glennon and/or Bray?

Possibly.

I think that when you compare them all on tape, Bray has the much better arm + strength of schedule throughout his career. He also has a poor release point, throwing motion, is inconsistent, and also has character issues stemming from throwing beer bottles.

Glennon has a solid arm but is shaky. Worse than Flacco coming from Delaware. Poor decision making, tends to check down on plays that don't warrant it, and consistently struggles on making throws outside the hash (deep outs, corners). I'd love to take him if my entire team was ready to compete and we were drafting at #25 or he could sit for 2+ years.

I think that Nassib's ability to move within the pocket along with his release is significantly better than both.

I think that the QBs will go Geno, Wilson, Barkley, Nassib, Glennon although any variation of the last 3 wouldn't shock me. Bray can sneak in there but he'd have to wow in interviews and throw well ( motion-wise) at his pro-day/combine.

[Exoter175]

Originally Posted by Sorter

Possibly.

I think that when you compare them all on tape, Bray has the much better arm + strength of schedule throughout his career. He also has a poor release point, throwing motion, is inconsistent, and also has character issues stemming from throwing beer bottles.

Glennon has a solid arm but is shaky. Worse than Flacco coming from Delaware. Poor decision making, tends to check down on plays that don't warrant it, and consistently struggles on making throws outside the hash (deep outs, corners). I'd love to take him if my entire team was ready to compete and we were drafting at #25 or he could sit for 2+ years.

I think that Nassib's ability to move within the pocket along with his release is significantly better than both.

I think that the QBs will go Geno, Wilson, Barkley, Nassib, Glennon although any variation of the last 3 wouldn't shock me. Bray can sneak in there but he'd have to wow in interviews and throw well ( motion-wise) at his pro-day/combine.

So you and I basically have the same rankings, except I have Glennn ahead of Nassib, and Bray ahead of both. I completely agree with your breakdown that you just wrote, but I'd really emphasize for bray his decision making issues that have been fairly prevalent. More often than not I've seen him try to force the deep ball because of his arm, rather than check it down, and often times throw into double coverage expecting his receiver to go up and get it. I just don't think his receivers are talented enough to really hide that shortcoming.

[Nightfyre]

Originally Posted by Sorter

Possibly.

I think that when you compare them all on tape, Bray has the much better arm + strength of schedule throughout his career. He also has a poor release point, throwing motion, is inconsistent, and also has character issues stemming from throwing beer bottles.

Glennon has a solid arm but is shaky. Worse than Flacco coming from Delaware. Poor decision making, tends to check down on plays that don't warrant it, and consistently struggles on making throws outside the hash (deep outs, corners). I'd love to take him if my entire team was ready to compete and we were drafting at #25 or he could sit for 2+ years.

I think that Nassib's ability to move within the pocket along with his release is significantly better than both.

I think that the QBs will go Geno, Wilson, Barkley, Nassib, Glennon although any variation of the last 3 wouldn't shock me. Bray can sneak in there but he'd have to wow in interviews and throw well ( motion-wise) at his pro-day/combine.

It is as if Sorter sees with my eyes. Creepy. Are you coming to the senior bowl or what?

[keg in kc]

Rather more one-sided than I expected.

[Exoter175]

Originally Posted by keg in kc

Rather more one-sided than I expected.

I have the opposite impression, I honestly thought it would look more one sided than this pre-combine.

[Ultra Peanut]

THOMAS TAPEH

[Wumbology]

Seth Doege. I'll say he's the next Russell Wilson so if he is actually good I can come back here and brag. If not, I'll just do my usual hang around and not post.

[Sorter]

Originally Posted by Wumbology

Seth Doege. I'll say he's the next Russell Wilson so if he is actually good I can come back here and brag. If not, I'll just do my usual hang around and not post.

I've just seen highlights so I really can't comment.

[Sorter]

Bray is Stafford minus being successful in the SEC and with worse footwork and decision making. Will still make some throws that leave your jaw dropping but isn't worth the #1 pick when you have Geno and Wilson still available.