Petro's back on the "drafting a QB is going to fail" rant

[htismaqe]

Basically saying again that the Chiefs should draft a 1st-round QB even though though history says it won't work.

[O.city]

So you have a 30% chance of getting the right QB in the first round, where as finding the right QB in rounds 2-7 COMBINED isn't that good?


The reason everyone wants a first round QB isnt because of some magic automatically great thing. It's because thats generally where the best overall QB's are drafted in each draft and gives you the best chance to get a frachise QB. If you want to play if all about averages and chances, its been shown that the 1st round is the best place to shop.

[Fansy the Famous Bard]

Originally Posted by Woodsponge Chuckpants

There are some people who think it is a shitty QB class.

there are 3 elite level QB prospects in this class. How is that shitty? That fits right into what we're looking for.

[Woodchuck]

Originally Posted by O.city

So you have a 30% chance of getting the right QB in the first round, where as finding the right QB in rounds 2-7 COMBINED isn't that good?


The reason everyone wants a first round QB isnt because of some magic automatically great thing. It's because thats generally where the best overall QB's are drafted in each draft and gives you the best chance to get a frachise QB. If you want to play if all about averages and chances, its been shown that the 1st round is the best place to shop.

It's common sense to figure that the first round is the best place to draft any position. What I am talking about is finding the right guy and the odds of doing so.

[Chiefnj2]

The moderators who allowed BlackBob back on CP should all publicly apologize to the board and impose a 1 year ban on themselves.

[HemiEd]

Originally Posted by Woodsponge Chuckpants

Let's talk about why it works...

First, it's about making one pro bowl. When a guy makes his first pro bowl, it's not because it was a popularity contest. Especially for QBs. It's because they deserved it.

Why did I say it means they were top ten in the league for that season? Because six QBs go to the pro bowl every year. A couple always don't show up. This system allows for four of six to bow out. There are always 2-4 who back out. Last year, Cam Newton and Andy Dalton went in place of Eli Manning and Tom Brady.

Every single first round QB should make at least one pro bowl imo. It is a passing league. If they can't make one, they are a first round bust.

So you think Cassel deserved to go to the Pro Bowl for the 2010 season? You think he was a franchise QB? **** the Pro Bowl, we just need a QB with the talent for the game, tough, pocket presence, good arm, intelligent that doesn't panic under pressure.

[O.city]

Originally Posted by Woodsponge Chuckpants

It's common sense to figure that the first round is the best place to draft any position. What I am talking about is finding the right guy and the odds of doing so.

So why are we talking about this? The first round is the best place to draft a qb, as that's where the best most qualified qbs are drafted.


You have a better chance of finding the guy there that any other round combined.

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

Originally Posted by the Talking Can

would you shut the **** up and kill yourself you god damn reerun

you are so ****ing stupid it makes the universe fall down a flight of stairs

Rep.

Originally Posted by Woodsponge Chuckpants

Let's talk about why it works...

First, it's about making one pro bowl. When a guy makes his first pro bowl, it's not because it was a popularity contest. Especially for QBs. It's because they deserved it.

.

FAILFAILFAILFAILFAILyou ****ing asshat die in fire!

[Mugalug]

Originally Posted by Chiefnj2

The moderators who allowed BlackBob back on CP should all publicly apologize to the board and impose a 1 year ban on themselves.

Harsh, but fair.

[the Talking Can]

Originally Posted by Chiefnj2

The moderators who allowed BlackBob back on CP should all publicly apologize to the board and impose a 1 year ban on themselves.

and drink aids

[Chris Meck]

Great! So, according to Petro, if we draft a QB in round 1 in 2013, we have a 30% chance of striking gold. If we do it again in 2014, we're up to 60%! That means more likely than not! If we have to do it again in 2015, we're at like 90%, so that's pretty certain! Way better than 40 years of not trying.

Just do it. You can't tell me that we're better off with Dorsey, Jackson, or even Berry really than a top notch QB. If you don't have one, do whatever it takes to get one.

[Hammock Parties]

We have a 100 percent chance of sucking ****ing ass if we go into next season with Cassel, Quinn or some other retread.

PERIOD.

[stevenidol]

Originally Posted by htismaqe

Actually, I didn't jump to any conclusions. I posted the OP before he FINISHED.

[Ebolapox]

Originally Posted by Woodsponge Chuckpants

Let's talk about why it works...

First, it's about making one pro bowl. When a guy makes his first pro bowl, it's not because it was a popularity contest. Especially for QBs. It's because they deserved it.

Why did I say it means they were top ten in the league for that season? Because six QBs go to the pro bowl every year. A couple always don't show up. This system allows for four of six to bow out. There are always 2-4 who back out. Last year, Cam Newton and Andy Dalton went in place of Eli Manning and Tom Brady.

Every single first round QB should make at least one pro bowl imo. It is a passing league. If they can't make one, they are a first round bust.

steve bono. matt cassel. elvis grbac. all three kc chiefs QBs, all three giant pieces of shit.

[vailpass]

Originally Posted by htismaqe

That awesome defense was predicated on Smith and Thomas. We wouldn't have gotten either of those guys if we had Marino.

Thanks for drafting Smith and breaking him in for us.

[Woodchuck]

Originally Posted by h5n1

steve bono. matt cassel. elvis grbac. all three kc chiefs QBs, all three giant pieces of shit.

Yep, and none of them were first round quarterbacks which is exactly what I am talking about.