Would you rather be 8-0 with Alex Smith or 3-5 with Geno?

[-King-]

Originally Posted by Sweet Daddy Hate

When it comes to player acquisition,I'm assuming one of them is, yes.



Chase Daniel = The Great Non-Threat. Care to debate that? You can't.



I do. Daily. But not worth 1.1/Dane McDerp

Yeah, Tavon Austin is really setting the NFL on fire right now.

[Molitoth]

Originally Posted by -King-

Yeah, Tavon Austin is really setting the NFL on fire right now.

Like Dwayne Bowe is?

WR's catching fire is all about the Chemistry they build with their QB's.

Look at the QB situation in STL and tell me any WR there is going to light up the NFL.

Tavon Austin could have a completely different stat sheet with a different QB.


Like I stated in another thread... Megatron would be used as a blocker for the KC Chiefs because Alex Smith won't throw downfield... especially into double coverage like Stafford does.

[Marcellus]

Originally Posted by Molitoth

Like Dwayne Bowe is?

WR's catching fire is all about the Chemistry they build with their QB's.

Look at the QB situation in STL and tell me any WR there is going to light up the NFL.

Tavon Austin could have a completely different stat sheet with a different QB.


Like I stated in another thread... Megatron would be used as a blocker for the KC Chiefs because Alex Smith won't throw downfield... especially into double coverage like Stafford does.

Yea because Bowe and Megatron are close to being the same WR.

This argument is also ridiculous when you consider who Bowe had at QB before and did just fine. Cassel, Huard, and Thigpen were just gunslingers right! Constantly winging it into double coverage right?

Oh wait, maybe the issue isn't all on Smith? Blasphemy!

[doomy3]

Originally Posted by Molitoth

Like Dwayne Bowe is?

WR's catching fire is all about the Chemistry they build with their QB's.

Look at the QB situation in STL and tell me any WR there is going to light up the NFL.

Tavon Austin could have a completely different stat sheet with a different QB.


Like I stated in another thread... Megatron would be used as a blocker for the KC Chiefs because Alex Smith won't throw downfield... especially into double coverage like Stafford does.

Oh, so now Alex Smith represents an upgrade over Sam Bradford?

[Molitoth]

Originally Posted by doomy3

Oh, so now Alex Smith represents an upgrade over Sam Bradford?

Just sayin... QB's have agendas.

Alex Smith plays it safe and does not throw into double coverage in risk of turning the ball over. Watch the Lions and tell me Stafford takes those same risks.

If Megatron played for the Chiefs, Alex isn't going to just "throw it up" for him to go get. It's not who Alex Smith is.

My point is, a WR's production is about chemistry with his QB. WR's don't all of a sudden just "suck".
Cassel trusted Bowe a hell of a lot more than Alex Smith does, thus his production was up.

[doomy3]

Originally Posted by Molitoth

Just sayin... QB's have agendas.

Alex Smith plays it safe and does not throw into double coverage in risk of turning the ball over. Watch the Lions and tell me Stafford takes those same risks.

If Megatron played for the Chiefs, Alex isn't going to just "throw it up" for him to go get. It's not who Alex Smith is.

My point is, a WR's production is about chemistry with his QB. WR's don't all of a sudden just "suck".
Cassel trusted Bowe a hell of a lot more than Alex Smith does, thus his production was up.

Bowe hasn't done anything so far to earn Smith's trust at all. Smith certainly has thrown balls to Bowe this year that required trust that Bowe would beat his man. Bowe lazily didn't fight for possession. That causes a QB to lose trust.

And Calvin is a different beast. If Smith threw jump balls in between 3 defenders to Bowe, it would likely not end well.

Andy Dalton isn't exactly some gun slinger, but when you're throwing to AJ Green, you're able to throw some jump balls knowing that he will likely win.

[Nightfyre]

Originally Posted by doomy3

Bowe hasn't done anything so far to earn Smith's trust at all. Smith certainly has thrown balls to Bowe this year that required trust that Bowe would beat his man. Bowe lazily didn't fight for possession. That causes a QB to lose trust.

And Calvin is a different beast. If Smith threw jump balls in between 3 defenders to Bowe, it would likely not end well.

Andy Dalton isn't exactly some gun slinger, but when you're throwing to AJ Green, you're able to throw some jump balls knowing that he will likely win.

Really? QB trust is the new excuse? Seriously, some you apologists are willing to bend over backwards to defend a guy who is completely mediocre.

[ShowtimeSBMVP]

Originally Posted by Nightfyre

Really? QB trust is the new excuse? Seriously, some you apologists are willing to bend over backwards to defend a guy who is completely mediocre.

Kinda like you with Royal players.

[doomy3]

Originally Posted by Nightfyre

Really? QB trust is the new excuse? Seriously, some you apologists are willing to bend over backwards to defend a guy who is completely mediocre.

Are you even following the conversation? He said that if Megatron was here that Smith wouldn't just "throw it up to him" like Stafford does, into double coverage. I said that Calvin and Bowe are completely different animals. Of course if a guy gives up on slant routes and that causes the QB to throw an INT that QB is going to lose some trust the next time the play is called.

Smith is mediocre and I'm not saying differently. He is the definition of a game manager, and so far he has done very well at managing games.

Quit reading everything looking for an agenda and maybe that will help you follow conversations a little better and will make you quit making an ass out of yourself.