Geno Smith is Sam Bradford

[MagicHef]

Originally Posted by patteeu

The quarterbacks were easy to check so I checked them and your number is incorrect. The technically correct number is 46% (12/26). If you give credit to Eli Manning and Philip Rivers as if they were drafted by NYG and San Diego respectively, the number is 54% (14/26).

So I'm not sure what your spreadsheet is doing, but I don't have confidence in your results.

Why don't you list the QBs that had overall winning records with their original teams? Yes, I am counting Eli and Rivers.

[patteeu]

Originally Posted by MagicHef

Why don't you list the QBs that had overall winning records with their original teams? Yes, I am counting Eli and Rivers.

Drew Bledsoe 63-60
Kerry Collins 22-20
Steve McNair 76-55
Peyton Manning 141-67
Donovan McNabb 92-49-1
Mike Vick 38-28-1
Philip Rivers 70-42
Eli Manning 78-57
Alex Smith 38-36-1
Vince Young 31-19
Matt Ryan 56-22
Mark Sanchez 33-29
Robert Griffin III 9-6
Andrew Luck 11-5

Here are the guys with losing records:

Rick Mirer 20-31
Heath Shuler 4-9
Ryan Leaf 4-14
Tim Couch 22-37
Akili Smith 3-14
Joey Harrington 18-37
David Carr 22-53
Carson Palmer 46-51
JaMarcus Russell 7-18
Matt Stafford 17-28
Sam Bradford 15-26-1
Cam Newton 13-19

[MagicHef]

Originally Posted by patteeu

Drew Bledsoe 63-60
Kerry Collins 22-20
Steve McNair 76-55
Peyton Manning 141-67
Donovan McNabb 92-49-1
Mike Vick 38-28-1
Philip Rivers 70-42
Eli Manning 78-57
Alex Smith 38-36-1
Vince Young 31-19
Matt Ryan 56-22
Mark Sanchez 33-29
Robert Griffin III 9-6
Andrew Luck 11-5

Here are the guys with losing records:

Rick Mirer 20-31
Heath Shuler 4-9
Ryan Leaf 4-14
Tim Couch 22-37
Akili Smith 3-14
Joey Harrington 18-37
David Carr 22-53
Carson Palmer 46-51
JaMarcus Russell 7-18
Matt Stafford 17-28
Sam Bradford 15-26-1
Cam Newton 13-19

The Panthers were 30-34 when Collins was on the team, Falcons were 47-48-1 with Vick, 49ers were 61-66-1 with Smith. You probably have starts, while I'm going by team record while they were on the roster, because starts don't work so well to compare guys like DTs.

[patteeu]

Originally Posted by MagicHef

The Panthers were 30-34 when Collins was on the team, Falcons were 47-48-1 with Vick, 49ers were 61-66-1 with Smith. You probably have starts, while I'm going by team record while they were on the roster, because starts don't work so well to compare guys like DTs.

OK, that could be the discrepancy. Yes, I'm using starts.

[OnTheWarpath15]

Originally Posted by MagicHef

The Panthers were 30-34 when Collins was on the team, Falcons were 47-48-1 with Vick, 49ers were 61-66-1 with Smith. You probably have starts, while I'm going by team record while they were on the roster, because starts don't work so well to compare guys like DTs.

So taking those three off the list, we'd be looking at 11/26 - or 42%

Not sure where you're getting 38%

[MagicHef]

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58

So taking those three off the list, we'd be looking at 11/26 - or 42%

Not sure where you're getting 38%

Yep. I was too slow posting my new list.