Chiefs Smith is the best QB on the roster right now - Page 14

Titty Meat · 08-12-2017, 11:46 AM

If Smith goes down this year the team is ****ed. He's clearly the best QB on the roster right now.

BlackOp · 08-15-2017, 11:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JohnV

This isn't tennis. He has a team around him, and the wins are more a reflection of their play than his.

So..by that rationale...Green Bay and New Orleans should hate their QB too and blame them for everything? Did Packer fans blame Rodgers for the guy fumbling the kick off in the playoffs?

Did Chief fans blame Kelce for dropping that pass against the Steelers? Did Chief fans blame Hali for dropping that INT vs. the Pats or Berry blowing his coverage against Gronk?

You're right..it takes a collective team effort.

PAChiefsGuy · 08-15-2017, 11:27 AM

Okay here's a question for all the Alex Smith haters. Are the Chiefs with Smith better or worse than they were before they signed him?

Lets see what the Chiefs record was 10 years before he came here. All playoff seasons in bold.

2012 2-14
2011 7-9
2010 10-6
2009 4-12
2008 2-14
2007 4-12
2006 9-7
2005 10-6
2004 7-9
2003 13-3

So we have 4 winning seasons in 10 years and 0 playoff victories.

Since Alex has been here

2016 12-4
2015 11-5
2014 9-7
2013 11-5

Since Alex has been here it's been 4 winning seasons in 4 seasons and three playoff seasons. Seems to me us Chief fans should be a little more appreciative of Alex Smith. Don't ya think?

Team game absolutely, but if a QB continues to win games despite a variety of circumstances you have to admit, we have a good QB IN KC! Not elite, not great but good and he certainly doesn't deserve all the insults he gets on this board.

Chiefnj2 · 08-15-2017, 11:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PAChiefsGuy

Okay here's a question for all the Alex Smith haters. Are the Chiefs with Smith better or worse than they were before they signed him?

Lets see what the Chiefs record was 10 years before he came here. All playoff seasons in bold.

2012 2-14
2011 7-9
2010 10-6
2009 4-12
2008 2-14
2007 4-12
2006 9-7
2005 10-6
2004 7-9
2003 13-3

So we have 4 winning seasons in 10 years and 0 playoff victories.

Since Alex has been here

2016 12-4
2015 11-5
2014 9-7
2013 11-5

Since Alex has been here it's been 4 winning seasons in 4 seasons and three playoff seasons. Seems to me us Chief fans should be a little more appreciative of Alex Smith. Don't ya think?

Team game absolutely, but if a QB continues to win games despite a variety of circumstances you have to admit, we have a good QB IN KC! Not elite, not great but good and he certainly doesn't deserve all the insults he gets on this board.

Your time would be more productive slamming your penis in your bathroom door. You aren't going to change anyone's opinion on Smith.

Rasputin · 08-15-2017, 11:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PAChiefsGuy

Okay here's a question for all the Alex Smith haters. Are the Chiefs with Smith better or worse than they were before they signed him?

Lets see what the Chiefs record was 10 years before he came here. All playoff seasons in bold.

2012 2-14
2011 7-9
2010 10-6
2009 4-12
2008 2-14
2007 4-12
2006 9-7
2005 10-6
2004 7-9
2003 13-3

So we have 4 winning seasons in 10 years and 0 playoff victories.

Since Alex has been here

2016 12-4
2015 11-5
2014 9-7
2013 11-5

Since Alex has been here it's been 4 winning seasons in 4 seasons and three playoff seasons. Seems to me us Chief fans should be a little more appreciative of Alex Smith. Don't ya think?

Team game absolutely, but if a QB continues to win games despite a variety of circumstances you have to admit, we have a good QB IN KC! Not elite, not great but good and he certainly doesn't deserve all the insults he gets on this board.

Thanks to the defense and special teams in that it's complete opposite of what Trent Green had. In that same time Rex Grossman won more playoff games and so did Mr. Buttfumbler Mark Sanchez that won more playoff games than Alex Smith. what are you trying to prove?

rico · 08-15-2017, 11:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PAChiefsGuy

Okay here's a question for all the Alex Smith haters. Are the Chiefs with Smith better or worse than they were before they signed him?

Lets see what the Chiefs record was 10 years before he came here. All playoff seasons in bold.

2012 2-14
2011 7-9
2010 10-6
2009 4-12
2008 2-14
2007 4-12
2006 9-7
2005 10-6
2004 7-9
2003 13-3

So we have 4 winning seasons in 10 years and 0 playoff victories.

Since Alex has been here

2016 12-4
2015 11-5
2014 9-7
2013 11-5

Since Alex has been here it's been 4 winning seasons in 4 seasons and three playoff seasons.

Seems to me us Chief fans should be a little more appreciative of Alex Smith. Don't ya think?

Team game absolutely, but if a QB continues to win games despite a variety of circumstances you have to admit, we have a good QB IN KC! Not elite, not great but good and he certainly doesn't deserve all the insults he gets on this board.

You Alexuals and your stupid questions.

Alex is not as bad as Cassel, no.

However...Alex would have done much worse these past few years with Pioli, Crennell and Daboll than he did with Dorsey, Reid and Pederson/Childress/Nagy.

BlackOp · 08-15-2017, 11:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RealSNR

By all accounts, Damon Huard played football Alex Smith style. And he won games with it. Had he been given Alex's defense and coaching staff, I imagine Huard could have amassed a pretty decent winning percentage in Kansas City.
.

So...you're saying it was a twist of unfortunate timing that Huard didn't have the 3rd most wins in the NFL over a 6 season span? It's just as easy as that...

CP Smith-hater logic on display...

rico · 08-15-2017, 11:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BlackOp

I love having a QB that can go into Denver and beat them, twice in a row, in their house...and ruin their season on Christmas in front of a national audience. Clowning the Raiders $25 million dollar QB four times in a row is a bonus too...

I am guilty of that..I'll admit.

People can hate on Smith..but he has owned the AFCW the past 2 years...11-1. How can any Chiefs fan be pissed about that?

He was also part of blowing out the Pats...and sending Brady-boy to the bench...on a national broadcast. He was part of benching Manningstien too... He might be the only QB to ever do that to both. Hate him if you want but that's pretty awesome...

That's fine, you give Smith a lot of credit for not throwing INT's that led to losses in those games and that's fine. You are not an Alexual trying to convert us, so I respect your opinion as an actual Chiefs fan.

I just think the guy has been blessed with an awesome team and and I give that supporting cast more credit than I do Alex...because the majority of his supporting cast is better than him. This team could be just slaughtering everyone.

Rasputin · 08-15-2017, 11:39 AM

I swear the more people try to convince me to like Alex Smith for whatever reason the more I'm going hate and despise him. **** retreads especially those from San Francisco.

PAChiefsGuy · 08-15-2017, 11:39 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rico

You Alexuals and your stupid questions.

Alex is not as bad as Cassel, no.

However...Alex would have done much worse these past few years with Pioli, Crennell and Daboll than he did with Dorsey, Reid and Pederson/Childress/Nagy.

Reid and Alex are a good combo, agreed. But it is called a combination for a reason.

I'm sure Reid would have done just as well with Cassel as his QB these past few seasons. Wouldn't you agree?

See how this works?

penbrook · 08-15-2017, 11:43 AM

Smitty was clutch last year. He single handedly brought us back from the biggest deficit in Chiefs history at halftime to win! He got us a TD against the best defense in the NFL in the Broncos last year with 2 minutes left to force a overtime. That's just a couple of moments.

JohnV · 08-15-2017, 11:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BlackOp

So..by that rationale...Green Bay and New Orleans should hate their QB too and blame them for everything? Did Packer fans blame Rodgers for the guy fumbling the kick off in the playoffs?

Did Chiefs fans blame Kelce for dropping that pass against the Steelers?

No, because they don't suck. They are the reason their team is there. They are their teams lifeline.

That's not Alex. He is inept at scoring points and that will come back to bite you at some point in the playoffs. Some people don't recognize his faults because he doesn't make too many obvious mistakes and you've won so many games with him being inept, but you're going to need better if you plan on going through playoff teams for a Super Bowl run

Rasputin · 08-15-2017, 11:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by penbrook

Smitty was clutch last year. He single handedly brought us back from the biggest deficit in Chiefs history at halftime to win! He got us a TD against the best defense in the NFL in the Broncos last year with 2 minutes left to force a overtime. That's just a couple of moments.

He wasn't clutch in the playoffs.

rico · 08-15-2017, 11:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PAChiefsGuy

Reid and Alex are a good combo, agreed. But it is called a combination for a reason.

I'm sure Reid would have done just as well with Cassel as his QB these past few seasons. Wouldn't you agree?

See how this works?

If you were around watching the Chiefs during the Cassel era you would realize that Cassel literally is the bottom of the barrel and never had any business being in the NFL to begin with. The guy didn't even start a game in college prior to the NFL. So no, it doesn't work this way...dumb comparison. This is Matt Cassel we are talking about...although I realize that probably means nothing to you since you've probably never seen him play.

And the funny thing is...I was at Arrowhead and personally witnessed Cassel out-perform Smith in 2010... I couldn't believe that I seemed to be witnessing a QB as incompetent as Cassel. It blew my mind.

threebag · 08-15-2017, 11:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BlackOp

So...you're saying it was a twist of unfortunate timing that Huard didn't have the 3rd most wins in the NFL over a 6 season span? It's just as easy as that...

CP Smith-hater logic on display...

Yeah he is a cock gobbling blow hard with a need to blast his cock sucker

BlackOp · 08-15-2017, 11:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KC Tattoo

He wasn't clutch in the playoffs.

He drove them back to tie the game...he made the 2 point conversion. He cant control the LT or the refs.

Unless that didn't happen and we watched different games...the defense had the chance to force a punt.

08-12-2017, 11:46 AM
Titty Meat Inmem 2.0 Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: My house Casino cash: $2107558	Smith is the best QB on the roster right now If Smith goes down this year the team is ****ed. He's clearly the best QB on the roster right now.
Posts: 75,312

08-15-2017, 11:27 AM	#197
PAChiefsGuy Best Body On ChiefsPlanet Join Date: Jan 2014 Casino cash: $2804900	Okay here's a question for all the Alex Smith haters. Are the Chiefs with Smith better or worse than they were before they signed him? Lets see what the Chiefs record was 10 years before he came here. All playoff seasons in bold. 2012 2-14 2011 7-9 2010 10-6 2009 4-12 2008 2-14 2007 4-12 2006 9-7 2005 10-6 2004 7-9 2003 13-3 So we have 4 winning seasons in 10 years and 0 playoff victories. Since Alex has been here 2016 12-4 2015 11-5 2014 9-7 2013 11-5 Since Alex has been here it's been 4 winning seasons in 4 seasons and three playoff seasons. Seems to me us Chief fans should be a little more appreciative of Alex Smith. Don't ya think? Team game absolutely, but if a QB continues to win games despite a variety of circumstances you have to admit, we have a good QB IN KC! Not elite, not great but good and he certainly doesn't deserve all the insults he gets on this board.
Posts: 5,881

08-15-2017, 11:39 AM	#203
Rasputin Tip of the hat LIV Champs Join Date: Jun 2007 Location: ks Casino cash: $3325421	I swear the more people try to convince me to like Alex Smith for whatever reason the more I'm going hate and despise him. **** retreads especially those from San Francisco. __________________ A Brave Man Once Requested Me To Answer Questions That Are Key 'Is It To Be Or Not To Be' And I Replied Oh Why Ask Me
Posts: 54,976

08-15-2017, 11:43 AM	#205
penbrook LEGEND! Join Date: Feb 2013 Casino cash: $10033840	Smitty was clutch last year. He single handedly brought us back from the biggest deficit in Chiefs history at halftime to win! He got us a TD against the best defense in the NFL in the Broncos last year with 2 minutes left to force a overtime. That's just a couple of moments.
Posts: 16,409