Cassel’s quarterback play isn’t inspiring hope

[ReynardMuldrake]

Cassel’s quarterback play isn’t inspiring hope

By SAM MELLINGER

SAN DIEGO | Really, they have so much reason to feel good in this place. The Chiefs played their best game of the season and even if that’s a classic thinnest-kid-at-fat-camp compliment, there is enough that the large men in this locker room should be smiling and whooping about.

Instead, the silence is broken only by the muted shuffling of equipment managers and the hushed questions from reporters about a blown opportunity.

And to be clear, it’s Matt Cassel who blew this opportunity.

The wake of the Chiefs’ 20-17 loss to the Chargers is a good time to wonder how many more chances he should get.

Because no matter how much lipstick the Chiefs try to put on it, this is the kind of failure that can stick with a guy, can change hearts and minds — and not in a good way.

The grassroots fan movement hoping for the Chiefs to stink their way into Stanford quarterback and assumed top overall pick Andrew Luck gained momentum. The players around Cassel look capable of doing their part, and Cassel has apparently regressed enough to create the need.

This is not the player general manager Scott Pioli envisioned when he used a trade and $63 million contract to secure him. Cassel is supposed to be the brand of quarterback who, as coach Todd Haley might say, “won’t do the kinds of things that get you beat.”

He is a facilitator and a protector of the football. The arm strength isn’t there for all the throws, but he made the Pro Bowl last year for throwing only seven interceptions. This is the kind of quarterback the Chiefs have built their offense, and much of their identity, around.

Well, what can you say now?

What happens when a 29-year-old quarterback starting his 48th game panics at the most crucial time and throws an interception on a screen pass?

“That’s obviously on me,” Cassel says. “I don’t have any words for that other than the fact that I’m hurting inside and I wish I could change it.”

Cassel has now thrown three touchdowns and five interceptions. Jacksonville’s Luke McCown is the only man in the league with a worse ratio, and he just got benched for a rookie. Cassel’s 5.2 yards per attempt are last in the league and would match the worst mark for a full-time quarterback in three seasons.

The Chiefs’ 0-3 record is not entirely on Cassel, of course. The offensive line is leaking and Jamaal Charles and Tony Moeaki are on injured reserve. This team’s problems go much deeper than one man, but this one stinks worse because of the context.

The Chiefs spent parts of Sunday looking like an actual NFL team for the first time all season, holding the Chargers to fewer than 4 yards per carry and confusing Chargers quarterback Philip Rivers into two interceptions (even if the refs may have missed a pass interference call on one of them).

The Chiefs were behind all day, Cassel ineffective enough through three quarters that the offense mostly became tiny Dexter McCluster running behind a broken line.

The Chiefs didn’t get a first down or a point or a positive passing play to a receiver until the third quarter. Cassel mostly continued his frustrating habit of throwing no more than 5 yards downfield, often just short of what’s needed for a first down.

Except the Chargers — working within the Norv Turner corollary — never took the invitation to make this a blowout. They generally moved the ball just enough to satisfy fantasy football owners, being careful to score only in response to the Chiefs’ scores.

After a historically inept first two games, criticism rising to the level of questioning Haley’s job security, a win here would’ve changed the entire conversation back in Kansas City.

Cassel could’ve done that, right here, the kind of 2-minute situation every kid plays out in the backyard. On first down, Cassel hit Leonard Pope down the left seam for 23 yards. Afterward, Haley called it “one of (Cassel’s) better throws of the last couple years.”

His next may have been his worst.

The Chiefs had what Haley and many of the players involved still think was the perfect play called at the perfect time. They knew the Chargers would bring outside pressure, especially from the weak side, so a screen pass to McCluster into the blitz could go for a big chunk.

Cassel kept his head downfield for the first few steps of his drop, and maybe it was the adrenaline of the moment, but when he swung his head back to the left, he blanked on safety Eric Weddle peeling out of his blitz and in front of McCluster.

“A ball I’d like to have back,” Cassel says.

“We can’t throw an interception there,” Haley says.

“We could’ve either thrown the ball into the ground, or could’ve done this, could’ve done that,” McCluster says. “But you know what? It didn’t happen. We’ve got to stick together and keep moving.”

Whether that includes Cassel is now seriously up for debate, the biggest topic of this Chiefs season. Maybe Ryan Succop would’ve missed the game-tying field-goal attempt, or maybe the Chiefs would’ve lost in overtime. It’s entirely possible that Cassel could’ve made the right decision and still be watching tape of a loss today.

But we’ll never know, and that’s the point.

The bigger vision of this offense is surrounding Cassel with enough playmakers and support to make up for his inadequacies and highlight what Pioli sees — saw? — as a critical ability to avoid major mistakes.

Even before Sunday, that thinking could be picked apart based on the Chiefs’ still having an obviously flawed roster in need of both depth and upgrades. Now, it can be blown up by the growing pile of evidence that Cassel is miscast even for the neutered role of facilitator.

The players around Cassel did enough that the talk today should be about hope. Instead, Cassel made the kind of mistake that forces you to wonder if he needs to be replaced to get that hope back.

http://www.kansascity.com/2011/09/25...ou-wonder.html

[DanT]

The writer of the cover story says that the Chiefs 0-3 start is not entirely on Cassell, citing among other things Charles' injury. Although it's true that the bad start is not entirely on Cassell, in my opinion, Charles' injury is at least in part on Cassell, as that injury was sustained in desperation. Charles got hurt trying to get something that the rest of his team was much less capable of getting, a first down. As they say, when opportunity meets preparation, good luck results. Well, when incompetence meets overpaid, condoms break, desperation is born and ligaments pop.

[BryanBusby]

This is me IRL when Cassel drops back to pass.

[Hammock Parties]

Originally Posted by BryanBusby

This is me IRL when Cassel drops back to pass.

I saw this and was wishing it had been Haley.

[Rasputin]

Originally Posted by bevischief

I am not a big Cassel fan but I believe his rib injury is worse than they let on.

Yea, Romo had a punctured lung or something right? Then if he can't handle it all the more reason for him to be gone.

[Ming the Merciless]

this guy is just now figuring this out?

wow...

[MahiMike]

Matt's trying to feel good about himself today.

[FAX]

It is, however, inspiring dope.

Anti-depressant sales in the Midwest have peaked to an all-time high.

FAX

[the Talking Can]

Originally Posted by BryanBusby

This is me IRL when Cassel drops back to pass.

loved that

"OH MY ****ING GOD!!!!!!"

[whoman69]

I want him gone yesterday. I'm wondering what his rating is going to be from ESPN and other non-traditional QB ratings. He had a 100 QB rating on a horrible game because he completed 70% of his passes. That should be pretty easy to do when you only throw the ball 6 yards down the field.

[Ace Gunner]

Originally Posted by suzzer99

As usual Cassel went to pieces under pressure. Cassel I, Cassel II and little mini Cassel born on 9/26/2001 at 4:25pm PST. Weighing in at 5.7 oz. Flushed on 9/26/2001 at 4:26pm PST.

nice. I always do my Cassel business in the morning

[suzzer99]

I've got a rancid hangover Cassel percolating that's just about ready to Cassel it's way out of my Cassel.

[Fish]

Originally Posted by hometeam

I still cant figure out why this fanbase ever settled for Cassel.

WHY CANT WE HAVE A BRADY OR MANNING?

Cassel, always has, and always will, be the the guy who just cant GET IT DONE.

Well.... when Pioli came to the site to ask us whether us fans felt he should trade for Cassel, the vote was pretty close at the time. The fans almost voted it down, in which Pioli would have declined the trade.. but no such Luck...

[Tribal Warfare]

Originally Posted by KC Fish

Well.... when Pioli came to the site to ask us whether us fans felt he should trade for Cassel, the vote was pretty close at the time. The fans almost voted it down, in which Pioli would have declined the trade.. but no such Luck...

nice!!!!!!

[HemiEd]

Originally Posted by hometeam

I still cant figure out why this fanbase ever settled for Cassel.

Yeah, it is a real puzzler, no doubt. I think GoatCheese was working for WPI at the time and they liked Cassel over there.

[Rooster]

Originally Posted by KC Fish

Well.... when Pioli came to the site to ask us whether us fans felt he should trade for Cassel, the vote was pretty close at the time. The fans almost voted it down, in which Pioli would have declined the trade.. but no such Luck...