Croyle better have a good game in Miami

[Wile_E_Coyote]

...because I see nothing

[TEX]

Originally Posted by ChiefsFanatic

If Dave Grohl suited up in place of Croyle, would we even be able to tell the difference?

I can't stand Croyle. I have watched football for a long time, and when I watch Croyle play QB, there is nothing I see that makes me think he is a Pro QB, now or in the future.

But, these experts on this board really know their stuff, and they post on the internet, so they must be right.

Yep. They all suffer from the "Emperor has no clothes" syndrome...
IMO, Brodie Croyle is not good enough to start in the NFL. It's pretty easy to see.

[Chiefs Pantalones]

I agree with TEX and ChiefsFanatic, but I'm trying to be positive about Croyle and hoping I'm wrong about him that he will be our starting QB for years to come. But I'm not placing any bets.

[ChiefsFanatic]

Originally Posted by TEX

Yep. They all suffer from the "Emperor has no clothes" syndrome...
IMO, Brodie Croyle is not good enough to start in the NFL. It's pretty easy to see.

These effing homer announcers just said that Thigpen had a tendency to stare down receivers. That must have come from a list of Carl approved lines intended to make Croyle look better.

[Wile_E_Coyote]

Be careful now, no room for any doubting. You will be labeled a troll or clueless

[JuicesFlowing]

Why didn't Huard play tonight?

[Bearcat]

Originally Posted by ChiefsFanatic

If Dave Grohl suited up in place of Croyle, would we even be able to tell the difference?

I can't stand Croyle. I have watched football for a long time, and when I watch Croyle play QB, there is nothing I see that makes me think he is a Pro QB, now or in the future.

But, these experts on this board really know their stuff, and they post on the internet, so they must be right.

I see flashes that make me believe he could be a good quarterback in this league, but it's hard to tell because of how bad the rest of the offense was last year.

Can you really expect much from a rookie quarterback in a Solari/Herm offense that has no running game and an awful offensive line? Even when he did succeed, like leading the offense down for the TD against Indy, the playcalling shut it down so he couldn't do it again.

People have posted stats several times, and his rookie stats were right there with some successful QB's rookie seasons, despite the other issues on offense.

I'm not trying to make excuses for the kid, because I'm not sold one way or the other, but it's his second year, and his first with Gailey. Despite what people see, and you could be right, it's just way too early to tell.

[Nightfyre]

And I suppose know-it-all chiefsfanatic, tex and Wile E all know better than say, people who make a ****ing living coaching and making these decisions.

[Deberg_1990]

Originally Posted by Bearcat

I see flashes that make me believe he could be a good quarterback in this league, but it's hard to tell because of how bad the rest of the offense was last year.

Can you really expect much from a rookie quarterback in a Solari/Herm offense that has no running game and an awful offensive line? Even when he did succeed, like leading the offense down for the TD against Indy, the playcalling shut it down so he couldn't do it again.

People have posted stats several times, and his rookie stats were right there with some successful QB's rookie seasons, despite the other issues on offense.

I'm not trying to make excuses for the kid, because I'm not sold one way or the other, but it's his second year, and his first with Gailey. Despite what people see, and you could be right, it's just way too early to tell.

I see flashes that he might be a good QB. But a superstar?? I dont see it.

He deserves the whole season ( i doubt he makes it through). We are kind of stuck with him this year anyways. But i have a strong suspicion, we will be looking for a franchise QB next April.

[Wile_E_Coyote]

Originally Posted by Nightfyre

And I suppose know-it-all chiefsfanatic, tex and Wile E all know better than say, people who make a ****ing living coaching and making these decisions.

Give us reason not to & not just name calling and headshaking

[beach tribe]

I'll be at the game. Gonna take some pics. I'll post them here

[beach tribe]

I think Croyle looks good, and will have a decent season

[ChiefsFanatic]

Originally Posted by Nightfyre

And I suppose know-it-all chiefsfanatic, tex and Wile E all know better than say, people who make a ****ing living coaching and making these decisions.

Not to brag, but I have won as many SuperBowls as a Head Coach as Marty and Herm combined.

And what is your point about people making a living coaching and making personnel decisions? You mean the great thinkers that did things like draft Todd Blackledge, Trezelle Jenkins and Ryan Sims? Yes, player evaluation is much better left to the experts.

[Nightfyre]

Originally Posted by Wile_E_Coyote

Give us reason not to & not just name calling and headshaking

Because the people who are paid professionals SAY SO.

[beach tribe]

Originally Posted by JuicesFlowing

Why didn't Huard play tonight?

Because Huard does not need to develop. He's already maxed out his back-up potential

[Nightfyre]

Originally Posted by ChiefsFanatic

Not to brag, but I have won as many SuperBowls as a Head Coach as Marty and herm combined.

And what is your point about people making a living coaching and making personnel? You mean the great thinkers that did things like draft Todd Blackledge, Trezelle Jenkins and Ryan Sims? Yes, player evaluation is much better left to the experts.

Do you have a control experiment to compare to? Then you have not a leg to stand on.