Romo/Rivers/Cutler..career losers or franchise QBs?

[Mav]

Originally Posted by Valiant

But some QBs are just there to not lose games.. game managers.. Dilfer and like..

Rather have a winner, than a stat stuffer. Leave the stat stuffing to FANTASY football.

Give me wins on sundays. give my team a chance in the playoffs.

The three in the OP, have never shown in their careers to be that guy that you need in the playoffs.

Especially ROMO.

[O.city]

Originally Posted by Mavericks Ace

Rather have a winner, than a stat stuffer. Leave the stat stuffing to FANTASY football.

Give me wins on sundays. give my team a chance in the playoffs.

The three in the OP, have never shown in their careers to be that guy that you need in the playoffs.

Especially ROMO.

When has romo ever had a defense and or a running game to help?

[KC_Connection]

Originally Posted by Mavericks Ace

Rather have a winner, than a stat stuffer. Leave the stat stuffing to FANTASY football.

Give me wins on sundays. give my team a chance in the playoffs.

The three in the OP, have never shown in their careers to be that guy that you need in the playoffs.

Especially ROMO.

Is Smith a "winner?" Because he wouldn't be winning anything on a team like Dallas.

[Mav]

Originally Posted by KC_Connection

Is Smith a "winner?" Because he wouldn't be winning anything on a team like Dallas.

Yeah. that's what they said about him being in KC too.

They opened up the offense for Colin Kaepernick too. They were 1-2, and went back to game managing, and have had two very convincing wins.

Amazing what relying on a strong run game, and protecting the ball will do for a team.

And to O.city, and Romo. They run that team through Romo. They have said that they are going to rely on him. They have a really good running back. They have a lot of pieces on defense. Unfortunately, they didn't stay with Rob Ryan long enough, and address their safeties to give him the help he needed.

Look at how he is doing with the Saints.

People cant have it both ways.

I didn't even mention Alex Smith.

This had nothing to do with him.

IN regards to Cutler, Romo, and Rivers, excuses are made for them, that aren't made for other qbs.

Rivers couldn't get it done, when he had LT. Vincent Jackson, Antonio Gates, and a great defense.

Cutler couldn't do it in Denver with Brandon Marshall, isn't doing it again in Chicago with a plethora of weapons, a great defense.

Romo, who has a hall of famer in Demarcus Ware, all of the offensive weapons. Dez, Miles, Witten.

8-8.

With Tom Brady, or Aaron Rodgers on that team, that is a 12 win team.