Who would you rather have drafting for the Chiefs?

[Reaper16]

The collective wisdom of ChiefsPlanet? No.

But the wisdom of some select posters at ChiefsPlanet is a more interesting question.

[jAZ]

Originally Posted by Bump

ya, I would rather have guys who are actually scouting the players and having people to evaluate them as their full time job....yeah.

I've said over and again that it's pretty stupid, IMO, for people to become so wound up with personal certainty about their opinions of a player when they have done, at most - 1/100th of the work to evaluate a draft.

Originally Posted by Reaper16

The collective wisdom of ChiefsPlanet? No.

But the wisdom of some select posters at ChiefsPlanet is a more interesting question.

... however, I'm a pretty big fan of the ideas beyond "Wisdom of Crowds". And while ChiefsPlanet doesn't provide all of the proper conditions for crowds to be wise, I'd rather go off the entire group than one or two "experts".

Between the real pros and the crowd, it's a closer call for me than I would have initially thought. But I'll go with the pros. Between the pros and a few "CP pros", it's no contest.

[NJChiefsFan]

Originally Posted by Reaper16

The collective wisdom of ChiefsPlanet? No.

But the wisdom of some select posters at ChiefsPlanet is a more interesting question.

While CP has it's own egos, if this scenario actually did happen I think most posters would take this serious enough to really lean upon the more well-versed scouting(relatively speaking) guys here. I honestly would take this place over *****. I am not saying that for this Front Office group. With ***** you can say that because honestly HOW could it get worse. Most people here were all for both Berry and Houston(at his spot in the 3rd). I don't think we could have done worse.