Alex Smith did, does, and will always suck. (part 2)

[Hammock Parties]

Old thread is archived here.

[htismaqe]

Originally Posted by Mac-NinersChiefs

The apparent reality that someone like you even has a daughter... ugh... how proud she would be to see you express yourself like this.

[The Franchise]

Originally Posted by Mac-NinersChiefs

The apparent reality that someone like you even has a daughter... ugh... how proud she would be to see you express yourself like this.

Seriously? Go **** yourself, dickbag.

[Marcellus]

Originally Posted by ChiefsCountry

If Alex Smith won us two Super Bowls like Eli or one like Flacco, I wouldn't give a shit if we gave him the 20 million dollar contract.

I hope we get to find out how ****ing reeruned that idea is.

[DJ's left nut]

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58

I understand where you're coming from, but how much of that is due to age, and the fact that there are a handful of guys that make it really hard to break through? It's damn near the same teams that are playing in late January and early February.

Some of it, for sure.

Some of it also comes from the fact that there are other really good players and smart football minds getting paid to beat you in a zero-sum environment. Winning in the playoffs, let alone winning the SB, is really damn hard and sometimes failing to do so doesn't mean much more than the other guys simply played better on that particular day

Which again gets me back to my original point - there are things far FAR more important to determining a player's value and long-term worth to an organization than his playoff record.

[Sandy Vagina]

Originally Posted by Pestilence

Go back and read JENKINSWINS posts on the subject. He first clarified that Smith had a better running game in SF until that was proven wrong. Then he stated that Charles's success is because of Alex Smith reading defenses.....proved wrong again.

That's fine... it's whatever at this point. In SF, every beatwriter was gushing about Alex's pre-snap reads and saying how it was frequently very helpful to the running production.

Whether that is true in KC, or was even true in SF... who can really say? You would literally have to break down each play while knowing the exact D-scheme and O-audibles to really know.

So again... it's whatever.. we wasted enough time on it. My comment was that it was well known (or often said) that Smith has excellent pre-snap diagnosis. I suspect this is true... and that it helps at times when JC rips off a big one after it looks like Smith changes the play. That's all.

[The Franchise]

Originally Posted by Mac-NinersChiefs

That's fine... it's whatever at this point. In SF, every beatwriter was gushing about Alex's pre-snap reads and saying how it was frequently very helpful to the running production.

Whether that is true in KC, or was even true in SF... who can really say? You would literally have to break down each play while knowing the exact D-scheme and O-audibles to really know.

So again... it's whatever.. we wasted enough time on it. My comment was that it was well known (or often said) that Smith has excellent pre-snap diagnosis. I suspect this is true... and that it helps at times when JC rips off a big one after it looks like Smith changes the play. That's all.

So then Matt Cassel is able to do the same thing....correct? More yards and a better YPC average?

[NinerDoug]

Originally Posted by Mac-NinersChiefs

The apparent reality that someone like you even has a daughter... ugh... how proud she would be to see you express yourself like this.

Originally Posted by Pestilence

Seriously? Go **** yourself, dickbag.

Funny thing about Alex Smith. The guy stirs up hatred like no other NFL player. Doesn't matter if he is playing shitty or playing well, he still puts MB posters at each others throats. Same thing still goes on in the NFL section on the Niners MB.

Very strange.

[BigCatDaddy]

Originally Posted by Mac-NinersChiefs

That's fine... it's whatever at this point. In SF, every beatwriter was gushing about Alex's pre-snap reads and saying how it was frequently very helpful to the running production.

Whether that is true in KC, or was even true in SF... who can really say? You would literally have to break down each play while knowing the exact D-scheme and O-audibles to really know.

So again... it's whatever.. we wasted enough time on it. My comment was that it was well known (or often said) that Smith has excellent pre-snap diagnosis. I suspect this is true... and that it helps at times when JC rips off a big one after it looks like Smith changes the play. That's all.

Because the San Fransciso Adam Teicher said so

[Sandy Vagina]

Originally Posted by Pestilence

So then Matt Cassel is able to do the same thing....correct? More yards and a better YPC average?

Well again... there are other variables that come into play... blocking from the OL being a big one... how well a RB is seeing the proper lanes, another.

I didn't pay much attention to Cassell... nor could I have known without question what he was changing the play to.

[htismaqe]

Originally Posted by Mac-NinersChiefs

That's fine... it's whatever at this point. In SF, every beatwriter was gushing about Alex's pre-snap reads and saying how it was frequently very helpful to the running production.

Whether that is true in KC, or was even true in SF... who can really say? You would literally have to break down each play while knowing the exact D-scheme and O-audibles to really know.

So again... it's whatever.. we wasted enough time on it. My comment was that it was well known (or often said) that Smith has excellent pre-snap diagnosis. I suspect this is true... and that it helps at times when JC rips off a big one after it looks like Smith changes the play. That's all.

[The Franchise]

Originally Posted by Mac-NinersChiefs

Well again... there are other variables that come into play... blocking from the OL being a big one... how well a RB is seeing the proper lanes, another.

I didn't pay much attention to Cassell... nor could I have known without question what he was changing the play to.

So your argument is......

Alex Smith makes Charles better. But you can't back it up or show stats to solidify your argument.

Got it.

[Sandy Vagina]

Originally Posted by NinerDoug

Funny thing about Alex Smith. The guy stirs up hatred like no other NFL player. Doesn't matter if he is playing shitty or playing well, he still puts MB posters at each others throats. Same thing still goes on in the NFL section on the Niners MB.

Very strange.

The occasionally intriguing thing about this is... as it was then... at some point, it stops even being about Alex Smith at all. It becomes poster vs poster.. and animosities of new and old exchanges.

[htismaqe]

Originally Posted by NinerDoug

Funny thing about Alex Smith. The guy stirs up hatred like no other NFL player. Doesn't matter if he is playing shitty or playing well, he still puts MB posters at each others throats. Same thing still goes on in the NFL section on the Niners MB.

Very strange.

The thing is, I don't hate Alex Smith. Actually, I like him. A LOT.

It's just a shame that it's not good enough. Anything less than undying man-love is "hater" talk.

[The Franchise]

Originally Posted by htismaqe

[htismaqe]

Originally Posted by Mac-NinersChiefs

The occasionally intriguing thing about this is... as it was then... at some point, it stops even being about Alex Smith at all. It becomes poster vs poster.. and animosities of new and old exchanges.

Probably because you're a ****ing douchebag.