Alex Smith did, does, and will always suck.

[Hammock Parties]

[Rausch]

Originally Posted by GoChargers

Hypocrite. You just got done calling Chiefs fans "pussies" for not licking Alice Smiff's balls, and now you want to whine about "childish mud-slinging."

True that.

Originally Posted by GoChargers

You have yet to post an interesting football take in all the time you've been here.

That's flat out dumbassery.

I may not agree with Clay-Darth-Pioli-PFF-than but he contributes.

[Sorter]

Originally Posted by TheUte

oh I like said I'm an optimist.

I have several bets that the Chiefs win the next game with the .

and if we lose because of AS I he get cut/traded.

I just don't think he is the reason we lost sunday.

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

Originally Posted by Chiefnj2

When receivers on the Packers or Saints drop a ball you think "that sucks, they blew an opportunity, but [Brees, Rodgers] will make that throw again."

When a KC receiver drops a ball you think "Oh crap, that was our one downfield shot this game and we blew it. Game over."

Exactly. NO room for error and ALL opportunities must come up roses, or we're ****ed.

It's a horrible, horrible way to predicate an offense.

But, but..."who was available"?

Answer:

Pick someone. Pick anyone but Cassel because the team had no faith in him, and roll with that guy for a season.
Same ****ing results offensively.

[TheUte]

Originally Posted by Sorter

haha, If we lose because of AS I hope he gets cut/traded.

[duncan_idaho]

Originally Posted by TheUte

Holy ****, where to begin.

I'm really sorry that I haven't been around long enough.

I really can't tell you how much your words hurt me.



Suck it up cupcake! it'll get better.

What are you basing the idea that it will get better on?

All indications are that this is who Alex Smith is. There's no reason - other than blind faith/hope - to believe Alex Smith can break career trends when asked to throw this often, in this style of offense.

[jd1020]

Originally Posted by TheUte

haha, If we lose because of AS I hope he gets cut/traded.

Alex will never be the reason the Chiefs lose, because it will be a certain catch that didn't miraculously wind up in the hands of a receiver, or Charles couldn't get a running game going, or a couple whiffs on blocking leading to sacks, or the defense not holding the opposing team to 3 points, or the refs "not being fair."

Take your pick.

[GoChargers]

Originally Posted by Rausch

I may not agree with Clay-Darth-Pioli-PFF-than but he contributes.

I seriously don't remember a post of Mac's that I've learned anything interesting from. Of course, throwing the WR's and O-line under the bus to prop up Alice doesn't interest me.

[Sorter]

Originally Posted by TheUte

haha, If we lose because of AS I hope he gets cut/traded.

Seems rash to make a decision based on one game without giving any context as to how the loss occurred.

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

Originally Posted by jd1020

Alex will never be the reason the Chiefs lose, because it will be a certain catch that didn't miraculously wind up in the hands of a receiver, or a couple whiffs on blocking, or the refs "not being fair."

Take your pick.

It's just the first season. He'll be Trent Green next year!/CP Casshole-Axl's

[Jakemall]

Originally Posted by duncan_idaho

I also love comparing Tom Brady's career accuracy to Alex Smith's.

Alex Smith is completing 58 percent of his passes this year. His career completion percentage is 59 percent.

Brady is completing 58 percent of his passes this year. His career completion percentage is 63 percent.

Alex Smith's accuracy the past two years in San Francisco is an extreme outlier for the rest of his career.

Many of the Smith critics expressed doubt that his impressive accuracy numbers from 2011 and 2012 would hold up when asked to throw far more often. So far, that has been the case.

I wouldn't expect Alex to stand up statisically with Brady. Brady will be going to the Hall of fame. I think Alex can be a good QB, but I don't forsee his ever becoming a great QB.

With that said, do you really think that the 49ers OL and WRs were anywhere near as talented as the Pats other than in 2011 and 2012 for the duration of Alex's career?


Edit: you're correct about the last 2 seasons being an outlier. Where we might disagree is the reason why.

[jd1020]

Originally Posted by Jakemall

I wouldn't expect Alex to stand up statisically with Brady. Brady will be going to the Hall of fame. I think Alex can be a good QB, but I don't forsee his ever becoming a great QB.

With that said, do you really think that the 49ers OL and WRs were anywhere near as talented as the Pats other than in 2011 and 2012 for the duration of Alex's career?

I'm not sure the Patriots win a SB without Deion Branch.

[Rausch]

Originally Posted by Sorter

Seems rash to make a decision based on one game without giving any context as to how the loss occurred.

I'm pretty ok with cutting/trading him now...

[Jakemall]

Originally Posted by TheUte

haha, If we lose because of AS I hope he gets cut/traded.

Gotta watch out for Sorter...he just sits and waits for people to make a mistake or spout something out their ass so he can swoop in like a hawk.

[SAUTO]

Originally Posted by jd1020

I'm not sure the Patriots win a SB without Deion Branch.

and the year brady was hurt cassel took like 50 sacks.

their line and wrs have sucked for years

[TheUte]

Originally Posted by Sorter

Seems rash to make a decision based on one game without giving any context as to how the loss occurred.

Well context is everything right.

I mean if we lose out and it's because AS is throwing int's or in some other way is clearly the only problem.

All I started out saying was the offense can improve for sure, Smith first.

But the entire offense needs improve a ton.

I also maintain that Avery's drop was big, I think plays like that are game changers. Even if they only score a FG it still a score and not a 3 and out.