Why Geno Smith fell in the draft

[BigCatDaddy]

Originally Posted by Messier

You believe this because you hate Alex Smith. I think he will be better than Geno or Manuel, or Barkley, at least in the short term, maybe always.

At the first pick in round two, I feel there was no QB that will be better than Alex Smith.

You want a team with major question marks at QB. The New York Jets.

I don't "hate" Alex Smith. I believe he is not a QB that is capable of "leading" a team to the SB, so I'd rather buy a scratch off ticket that gives me a 10-20% chance of getting that guy.

[Chief Roundup]

Originally Posted by BigCatDaddy

I don't "hate" Alex Smith. I believe he is not a QB that is capable of "leading" a team to the SB, so I'd rather buy a scratch off ticket that gives me a 10-20% chance of getting that guy.

I would like to see what those percentages actually are, based on past SB winning QBs and where they were drafted.
We have all seen where the 1st round QB dominates the SB wins category.
But I would imagine that it is less than 5% of 1st round QBs ever win a SB.