Peyton or Trent????

[CASHMAN]

Who should i start????

[Phobia]

Flip a coin this week, dude. Both have very tough defensive opponents.

In this situation, I think I'd probably go with Manning. In fact, I'd go with Manning every week this year except for his bye and if the Pats are up against the Titans while the Chiefs have the Chargers.

[RedNFeisty]

Peyton all the way! Love Trent, but it is what it is!!

[Rausch]

Manning. He seems to know he's a fantasy stud and loves it.

BTW, he calls one more ****ing audible during my madden game and I'm going to trade for him and bury him so far down on my bench he'll NEVER see the field again....

[OldTownChief]

I'd go Manning but I suck at FF.

[RINGLEADER]

Who's Manning playing? I'd still probably go Manning because Trent doesn't seem to wake up and start playing well until week 4 or 5.

[Taco John]

You always start the stud and leave your back-up on the bench when the stud is playing.

This isn't even a question.

Peyton Manning should be starting every week except his bye week, at which point you can THEN put your back-up in...

[David.]

manning. Even though I hate him, he's damn good.

[SBK]

Start Manning and trade Green for a RB....