[Mav]

Originally Posted by chiefzilla1501

Good grief. Please stop comparing Alex Smith to the elite QBs in the game. Just stop.

And by the way, Aaron Rodgers has some of the worst RBs and O-line to support him. And Rodgers, Brees, Brady, and Peyton have all excelled with some shitty supporting casts due to injury. Rodgers played in a Super Bowl with his #3 guy as his #1. Brees once played with Terrence Copper as one of his #1 guys. Peyton played with Garcon as his #1 once. And Brady made the AFC Championship with Reche Caldwell and Jabar Gaffney as his #1 guy.

You need to understand the concepts. The original comparison, was from VICK, AND CAM, TO ALEX, I wasn't the one who brought up Manning and Rodgers, I was just as floored as you were

Originally Posted by ChiefsCountry

In the same offense, they go from Alex Smith throwing 19 deep balls to Kaepernick throwing 49. Just shows Alex Smith is a no balls pussy when it comes to throwing deep.

Or, Kaepernick has the strongest arm in the League. They also had a lot more times where the deep ball was needed because of shootouts with the patriots, and getting blown the hell out by the seahawks?

Originally Posted by Alex Smith HATER

I am not talking about bombs.

We need a passing offense that can effectively complete passes in the 15-35 yard range. Green was very good at that range, even though his deep ball wasn't very good.

Alex Smith isn't. And it's going to cost us.

I also don't think Alex Smith is good in the red zone. If you take a look, he threw the fewest TD passes in the entire NFL in 2011 when his team was in the red zone. His completion percentage and, of course, yardage, was also extremely low.

When the opposing team knows your QB can't put the ball in the end zone, bad things happen to your offense. That's just common sense.

Who were his receivers in 2011. 3rd time today I have called you on this, and all of them you have ducked. You know that supporting cast was shitty. And the Ironic thing about the red zone in 2011. That was considered a strong suit of Alex Smiths prior to 2011. And Kaepernick did NO better when he took over.

Originally Posted by duncan_idaho

Your GIF post failed.

That is the best pass I've seen him make, though. If he would make that throw all the time, he might actually be an above-average QB. This is what Andy Reid is working on, I guess ... we'll see if it works.

That was a third down play with less than 30 ticks left off the clock, when a FG does San Francisco no good. As it is, I don't think you see that throw in normal situations.

Wrong. They were down by 3. A fg would of sent it to over time. Alex Smith made that play happen. And he has thrown a lot of passes like that. 6 come back wins led by him that year.....and it wasn't his only game winning td pass either. Beat the Lions at Detroit like that.

Originally Posted by Alex Smith HATER

2011 paints the most accurate and complete picture of Alex Smith.

Yes, a qb self teaching the offense to a team that he doesn't have a contract with because of the lockout, when your number one wide out refuses to come learn it, and then misses training camp, and all of the preseason with pussitis. His number one receiving threat says that he didn't understand the offense until week 10, saying that he was so frustrated that he wanted to quit. yeah, I agree. Shouldn't use the season that was most recent and actually showed what alex could do with solid players around him, and having complete control of the offense. I too choose to use what best fits my description and perception of a player.