Brett Kollman DE & DT Tiers

[Meatloaf]

Haven’t seen this anywhere on CP, so I thought I’d post them. Kollman has a couple of YouTube vids where he goes in depth on each guy. Interesting. Anyway, here are his Tiers:

DE T1
Will Anderson, Alabama
Tyree Wilson, Texas Tech
Nolan Smith, Georgia
Myles Murphy, Clemson
DE T2
Lucas Van Ness, Iowa
Keion White, GA Tech
Will McDonald, Iowa St
Bryon Young, Tenn
BJ Ojulari, LSU
Derick Hall, Auburn
Dylan Horton, TCU
Tuli Tuipulotu, USC
Felix Anudike-Uzomah, KSU
DE T3
Nick Hampton, App St
Zach Harrison, Ohio St
Isaih Foksey, ND
Jose Ramirez, E Mich
Yasir Abdulla, Louisville
Ya Ya Diaby, Louisville
KJ Henry, Clemson
Mike Morris, Mich
BJ Thompson, SFAustin
Nick Herbig, Wisc
Derek Parish, Hou
Dante Stills, W VA
Ikenna Enechulou, Rice
Desjuan Johnson, Toledo
Andre Carter, Army

DT T1
Jalen Carter, Georgia
DT T2
Calijah Kancey, Pitt
Keeanu Benton, Wisc
Mazi Smith, Mich
DT T3
Adeyomiwa Adeboware, Northwestern
Jerrod Clark, Coastal Car
Kobie Turner, wake Forest
Bryon Young, Ala
Bryan Bresee, Clemson
Gervan Dexter, Fla
DT T4
Jaqueln Roy, LSU
HestavJade Silvera, AZ St
Moro Ojomo, TX
Siaki Ika, Baylor
Keondre Coburn, TX

Kollman’s YouTube assessments are long, extensive and very informative. FYI.

[kccrow]

Originally Posted by Meatloaf

Hi Crow! Like your breakdown a lot. Where would you place Byran Bresee from Clemson? Personally, I think he's generally been ranked too high by most pundits. How do you see him?

Didn't realize I missed him. A very hesitant Tier 2. He's missed alot of games but he's a good player when he's healthy. I think best fit is 43-3T.

Originally Posted by Dunerdr

I think they avoid putting them in a box so that later they can say " Well teams told me they view him as a 3-4 outside rusher, so i had him here. Thats the only reason i was wrong."

Also it appears im higher on Jaquelin Roy than everyone else.

Yeah I get that segment. I think by doing it this way it maximizes their value. I don't think a guy I might have labeled as a 34-5T is as valuable to many 4-3 teams because he's either a rather linear and oversized end or an undersized 3T. Not that they can't fit but they might not be regarded as highly by those teams. Same goes for a 3-4 OLB prospect as a 4-3 DE.

Originally Posted by Direckshun

DraftTek is not the best draft website out there, but they absolutely nail this aspect of it.

They have been getting better every year. They aren't terrible, that's for sure. Far better than Walter.

[Mecca]

Bresee is like Murphy their tape from 2 years ago is a lot better so it's what do you think you can get out of him?