Every NFL team's best Hall of Famer

[lewdog]

I'm sure there's some good discussion here.

[RollChiefsRoll]

PATRICK MAHOMES

[Why Not?]

Originally Posted by Gary Cooper

I remember Mills but I'm surprised Julius Peppers isn't the Carolina choice. Mills only played several seasons in Carolina later in his career. Peppers was there longer and was one of the league's best pass rushers at the time.

I think he is actually only now HOF eligible. He'll get in, and immediately replace Mills on this list.

[Why Not?]

NFL players don't go into the HOF with a team designation. Peyton Manning is a better player than John Elway was. The Broncos entry should also be Peyton Manning.

[Ocotillo]

Originally Posted by Why Not?

I think he is actually only now HOF eligible. He'll get in, and immediately replace Mills on this list.

Julius Peppers got popped for steroids. He's not exactly a shoo in.

[Chiefshrink]

Originally Posted by cdcox

For the AFL era Chiefs, I’d argue Bobby Bell (voted 1st team all-pro five consecutive years) over Willie Lanier. I think many people would take DT over both.

Bill Bellichek would agree and said as much that Bell was the best he ever saw.

[Ocotillo]

Originally Posted by Why Not?

NFL players don't go into the HOF with a team designation. Peyton Manning is a better player than John Elway was. The Broncos entry should also be Peyton Manning.

This is a ridiculous argument, too.

Manning had three years with the Broncos (2012-14). Defense carried him in 2015.

Elway, albeit overrated, was a great QB from 1993-98 in the West Coast offense. Six years > Three.

[Gary Cooper]

Originally Posted by Why Not?

I think he is actually only now HOF eligible. He'll get in, and immediately replace Mills on this list.

I forgot Peppers played until he was like 50.

Jaromir Jagr still has at least five seasons until he's HHOF eligible.