Rock N Poll: Round 2, Heat 11

[patteeu]

Originally Posted by Rain Man

And I think your criterion is the way to go. It's easy to pick a song because "common knowledge" says it's a classic. But I think here we want to pick out the best song based on our own collective tastes. Otherwise, I'd just put up a Stairway to Heaven vs. Freebird poll and call it good.

I basically agree, although I think it's OK for everyone to decide on what criteria they want to use. I think it's OK for DJ's Left Nut to decide to only choose "suckage" if he doesn't choose any of the other songs. I think it's OK for Phobia to choose the songs he likes the most right now. I think it's OK for KC Tattoo to only choose songs either made by Guns N Roses or covered by them. I think it's OK for Mr. Flopnuts to vote on the basis of his Rolling Stones most influential rock of all time cheatsheet. The only thing that's not OK is for anyone to pay attention to Reaper's definition of metal.

My personal criteria is that I only vote for songs that Omaha finds cheesy.