Smith is the best QB on the roster right now

[dls6501]

Originally Posted by PAChiefsGuy

That's a very good point. I guess I'd say it is because his playoff stats are rather impressive. I think he currently has 12 TDs 2 INTs decent amount of yds, compl % also decent. His playoffs passer rating is also very good.

But winning in the playoffs is definitely an area Smith and Reid have struggled since they have been here but I think a variety of factors have played into that. Overall except maybe Steelers gm and Houstn gm (which we won anyway) he has played well.

We have to stay healthy and get that run D fixed. IMO if we do that we can beat anyone including the Patriots.

Thanks for the response. My issue I have with your response is the fact that Alex fans pointing at his stats are doing exactly what some of us do when our team carries Alex to a regular season win, but the opposite.

Alex has 185 yards, 0 TDs and we hear from the Alex crowd that we won the game, so stats are irrelevant.

Then, when we lose a playoff game and Alex plays really, really well (Colts game), we have to hear how well Alex played and are directed to look at his statistics. Its very contradictory.

This is why I personally, NEVER use winning percentage to judge how good or bad a QB is. To me, it is one of the more brainless ways one could analyze QB play.