Peyton Manning

[Amnorix]

Originally Posted by Tango&Cash

Who's better, Brady or Manning?

Put Brady on the Colts and Manning on the Pats and I'd bet Peyton Manning would have more SB's than Tom Terrific right now.

Based on what? His ability to choke in big games early in his career? The complete lack of elite offensive players around him (if he were playing for the Patriots), especially at the WR spot, until 2007? His inability (if he were playing for the Pats) to played in domes 9 games per year (8 at home, plus one in Texas) plus another game in perfect-weather-360-days-a-year-or-your-money-back-Jacksonville to help pad his stats, instead of playing in crappy New England weather, plus games in Buffalo and New York?

When splooging over his stats, remember what he's had to work with, and the inherent advantages he's had in his situation.