Geno Smith vs Alex Smith - It's on.

[Hammock Parties]

It's on now. Geno Smith is probably going to be starting for the Jets this season.

Alex Smith will be the Chiefs QB for the forseeable future. If he's a success, we'll probably get five good years out of him.

So who's gonna win more NFL games over that time period?

Put your ten pounders on the table and make a vote

Alex: 11 wins
Geno: 8 wins

[Dinny Bossa Nova]

Originally Posted by Sweet Daddy Hate

Sounds like Danielssssss.

The other sounds like Smith.



hahahahaha Oh, Lil'Chiefy; you crack me up.

Given your track record of QB evaluation, have you considered toning it down this time? Sanchez' legacy will be the butt fumble. I wonder if Geno can top that?

Dinny

[Marcellus]

Originally Posted by Dinny Blues

Given your track record of QB evaluation, have you considered toning it down this time? Sanchez' legacy will be the butt fumble. I wonder if Geno can top that?

Dinny

The irony of Smith competing with Buttfumble for a job and the lack of separation between the 2 is the best part of this.

[Carlota69]

Originally Posted by KC Tattoo

My problem with Alex Smith isn't that he would play good or bad but somewhere in between. Average. He is just an average quarterback that isn't going take us beyond a first round in the playoffs. He will do enough to keep his job and prevent us from drafting and coaching up potential franchise quarterback.

Well, he was on a team, and part of the reason why the team got past a first round in the playoffs. However, I think your "absolute" is closer to what will really happen.

Hopefully he helps keep us competitive til Reid and Co find the QB that will get us to the promise land. I'd rather be able to watch football than have another 2-14 season.

[FRCDFED]

I would like for us to take a shot at AJ McCarron next season. Flame away!

[Mav]

Originally Posted by Carlota69

Well, he was on a team, and part of the reason why the team got past a first round in the playoffs. However, I think your "absolute" is closer to what will really happen.

Hopefully he helps keep us competitive til Reid and Co find the QB that will get us to the promise land. I'd rather be able to watch football than have another 2-14 season.

Andy Reid thinks he can win with him. Alex's biggest problem is that he is gun shy. He would rather punt than make a risky throw on 3rd and long.

Lets be honest. And people don't want to hear this. Just like the 49ers have been trying to do for 3 years, the Chiefs have the same exact problem. Their wide receiver corps is weak. The 49ers receivers corps is still weak.

There is this false believe that Aaron Rodgers, Drew Brees, could do what they are doing with just anyone. They don't need the coaching, or players around them, they are just that good.

[Mav]

Originally Posted by FRCDFED

I would like for us to take a shot at AJ McCarron next season. Flame away!

there are a lot of prospects out there that are intriguing.

Bridgewater, McCarron, NOT MANZIEL, Bryn Renner, Tahj Boyd, Aaron Murray, the kid from Oregon, Logan Thomas.

Intriguing.

[Kaepernick]

Originally Posted by Mavericks Ace

Shakes head. Yet if anyone was to blame Kaepernick for the failure that was last season, you guys would throw a fit. I guess we call those Kaepexcuses.

The bottom line is that no player has ever been responsible for the success or failure of an entire team.

There are no Alexcuses here. I willingly admit that his limited ability set back some of offense. But every other reason, not excuse that I provided is valid.

And I don't care that you wont acknowledge it.

Just with your view of Alex Smith, then Kaepernick was the reason the 49ers lost their first super bowl.....Congrats. We have had two failures at qb the past two years. lets just hope Kaepernick can make a 5 yard pass this year.

Originally Posted by CSN bay area

“I feel like I made too many mistakes for us to win,” Kaepernick said, via CSNBayArea.com.


Kaepernick took full responsibility for the Super Bowl loss without making any excuses. Why should we?


“Things weren’t working in the first half,” Kaepernick said. “We just didn’t finish our drives. We turned the ball over a couple times. That was the difference in the game.”

http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com...per-bowl-loss/

His defense gives up an insurmountable 34 points that no winning SB team has ever overcome, he brought his team back from a 22-point deficit to within 5 yards of winning, and he blames himself.

Heart and Soul of a Champion.

[Kaepernick]

Originally Posted by Jakemall

Question what was the 49ers 3rd down conversion ratio when they ran? what was it when they passed?

Wow...I guess Gore sucks more than Alex then...or there's more to the stat then what you're suggesting.

How many of those 3rd down situations were 7+ yards?

Double standard some fans have..It's all Alex's fault when the team sucked, but when the team was good he had nothing to do with it.

Please note, I'm not saying that Alex carried the team on his back. But he was a big part of why they were successful.

I am almost saying the same thing, but I'm not.

I would say, "Alex was part of why they were successful, not a big part".

We just disagree.

[Sandy Vagina]

Originally Posted by Kaepernick

I am almost saying the same thing, but I'm not.

I would say, "Alex was part of why they were successful, not a big part".

We just disagree.

Would you also agree that the playcalling and deliberate leaning on the D and STs was part of the coaches' plan... and that this also plays a huge part in the 3rd down conversion results?

[Kaepernick]

Originally Posted by Mac-NinersChiefs

I really don't get why many are so butthurt at the 49ers fans here. So long as it wasn't division rivals or the Cowpukes, we all enjoyed having other team's fans visit the 49ers forum and talk it up. Why are KC fans so miserable and xenophobic? Must be the Patriots/Cassell thing, for the most part, I guess.

If you just talk straight football and be decent human beings, then there would be no issue at all. I'm telling you... you are creating your own misery.

Um... Because it is a KC CHIEFS forum.

Just a wild ass guess there. Maybe they embrace Seahawks and Steelers fans.

[Mav]

Originally Posted by Kaepernick

His defense gives up an insurmountable 34 points that no winning SB team has ever overcome, he brought his team back from a 22-point deficit to within 5 yards of winning, and he blames himself.

Heart and Soul of a Champion.

Yeahhhh, his turnover had nothing to do with that deficit. His shitty first half play had nothing to do with that.

Alex Smith didn't exactly ever throw anyone under the bus for his short comings did he? Unlike your boy crabtree who routinely threw alex under the bus........

Get over it. The bottom line is this. You swore you couldn't wait till alex smith was gone, and you didn't have to talk about him anymore, yet, you are still here.

This is me, holding your feet to the fire with your words........

[Kaepernick]

Originally Posted by Mac-NinersChiefs

Would you also agree that the playcalling and deliberate leaning on the D and STs was part of the coaches' plan... and that this also plays a huge part in the 3rd down conversion results?

Do you want to continue this on the 49ers forum? Because the Chiefs fans want us to STOP talking 49ers on THEIR FORUM.

[Sandy Vagina]

Originally Posted by Kaepernick

Do you want to continue this on the 49ers forum? Because the Chiefs fans want us to STOP talking 49ers on THEIR FORUM.

You merely had to answer the question instead of side-step it.

This whole, "it's a Chiefs forum" is ****ing stupid too. They don't have to click into this thread and can put us on ignore if they really had issues with us talking about Alex Smith.. who is not a 49er but is a Chief.

I mean, we ARE discussing threads talking about how to poop and how to protect oneself against home invasions.. Are they exclusive to talking about the Chiefs? SMDH

[Mav]

Originally Posted by Mac-NinersChiefs

You merely had to answer the question instead of side-step it.

This whole, "it's a Chiefs forum" is ****ing stupid too. They don't have to click into this thread and can put us on ignore if they really had issues with us talking about Alex Smith.. who is not a 49er but is a Chief.

I mean, we ARE discussing threads talking about how to poop and how to protect oneself against home invasions.. Are they exclusive to talking about the Chiefs? SMDH

pffffff. Hes embraced here because hes an Alex Smith hater. He wont go back and look at the super bowl drive for drive like I just did. he will realize how poorly Kaep really played, and his 41 qbr, and 91 rating, being overshadowed by his pathetic 2/9 3rd down conversions, his ill timed sacks taken that cost drives, or his interception in the first half.

Those are mere blackout after thoughts for him.

The fact is this. The 49ers receivers, have been weak as hell since T.O. and Jerry rice were the starting receivers.

But qbs make your receivers better is what I keep hearing around here. Their only example people can give me, is how Kaep made Crabtree better. But no mention of how much worse every other receiving option got on the 49ers.

The Chiefs, just like the 49ers have pathetic receiving options.

And its not going to matter much who the qb is in Kansas City until that changes......

[Kaepernick]

The Chiefs fans have asked us nicely and not so nicely 1000 times now to quit talking about the 49ers. I was wrong to post up about Kaepernick because that is a 49ers discussion.

As relates to Alex, anything 49ers related pertinent to Alex or the future of the Chiefs is fair game. But our side discussions about past 49ers history, is just pissing the Chiefs fans off more and making us look like bigger and bigger jackasses.

We have to knock it off. We really do.